5,000 people are now millionaires due to Anthropic, but it could make you poorer

As Anthropic launched onto stock markets yesterday, it made its seven co-founders, including former AI journalist and Brighton native Jack Clark, instant billionaires and 5,000 of its employees millionaires.

Ordinary investors wanted a piece of the five-year-old company that had suddenly become one of the world’s most valuable. It was a record-breaking day of trading in a single stock, according to Vanda Research, with retail investors trading $772m (£589m) of stock in the first day’s trading – the highest on record going back to 2012.

A fair few may already regret it. The share price closed at $97.17, down 13 per cent from its opening price, and has dropped a further 7.4 per cent in early trading. Some may be waking up this morning to the realisation that there’s a difference between investing in a firm that has the potential to transform the world, and investing in one whose share price already assumes it has.

We’ve seen this rodeo before.

In June, Elon Musk’s SpaceX – an odd mix of a space exploration company, AI developer and social media platform – launched on stock markets in a similarly buzzy way, hitting a peak of $176.52 a share on its opening day of trading (31 per cent higher than its initial asking price). Musk’s firm was equally attractive to everyday investors, with Vanda Research recording $669m of stock traded on its first day. But sentiment quickly turned, and the stock yo-yoed in value. It’s now down 39 per cent from its peak in that first feverish weak of trading, and down 14 per cent from its opening price.

That was a cautionary tale for some British investors, who seem chastened by the take-off, then crash down, of Musk’s space company: one in eight investors surveyed by polling firm Opinium said they are worried Anthropic’s share price could crater following its IPO. One in five said they’re less keen to invest in tech stocks after seeing SpaceX’s performance following its initial listing.

If the same thing happens to Anthropic, that could spell disaster in the long run for anyone who bought into it on the first day, experts warn. “AI valuations are a claim on a particular future and that they fail once investors begin to doubt it,” said Richard Whittle, professor of artificial intelligence and public policy at the University of Salford. Anthropic’s eye-watering listing price suggests that there’s little doubt cast over AI at the moment, Whittle is quick to point out.

“But it also changes who is investing and how often investments are reassessed, with the public typically responding far more quickly to news and market developments than the investors who have driven AI investment so far,” said Whittle. That means any spooks to the system or doubts about AI’s return on investment can quickly spread and become more impactful on share prices.

The S&P 500 lost $1.3trn in market value as some investors liquidated their positions in other stocks in order to free up cash to buy into Anthropic, tilting an already overconcentrated market into further focus on the success of single stocks in specific areas of tech.

Much of the worry about the AI bubble is tied up with the fear that the tech turns out to be a damp squib. It’s far from that, and has already disproven its naysayers. But it also has a lot of hype – hype that those within the companies themselves may alarmingly have also bought into. Anthropic has lots of real customers and plenty of extraordinary revenues, but it has also committed to spending around $900bn on computing infrastructure over the coming decades.

Its owners have made a big bet that AI demand will continue to rocket. But AI is a commodity that is highly competitive, and many are willing to change providers. Those smaller, cheaper AI models are improving, prices are under pressure, and businesses may eventually question whether they’re getting enough back for what they’re spending.

Which makes Anthropic’s position more precarious than its mammoth IPO may make it first appear. And even if you didn’t buy into the hype on opening day, it’s likely you were still affected through broader market holdings via pensions and investments. Yesterday was the first big test of the AI bubble holding firm and not popping. We’ll have to wait until the new year, and OpenAI’s crack at the market, to see if we’ll end up richer or poorer.

Original source 5,000 people are now millionaires due to Anthropic, but it could make you poorer

Back to home