Benefits overhaul would halve number of Neets in a decade

Alan Milburn’s plan to rewire the welfare system would halve the number of young people not in education, employment or training – or “Neet” – in the next decade, The i Paper can reveal. 

An impact assessment due to be published alongside the Labour grandee’s report also estimates that Milburn’s reforms will lift 50,000 people out of relative poverty by 2036/37.

Milburn – who was tasked with finding a way to support nearly one million under-25s classed as Neet – will publish his final report following a year-long review into youth joblessness on Tuesday. 

However, he acknowledged on Sunday that it could take a decade for the welfare bill to fall as a result of his reforms. 

He will recommend the package of reforms including changes to the benefits system, job subsidies and apprenticeships, education policy and a shift in the way mental health support is delivered.

The i Paper understands that an impact assessment included in the Milburn Review projects that 500,000 more young people aged 16 to 24 will be in education, employment or training by 2036/37 as a result of the reforms. Of these, 440,000 are expected to be in work.

This compares to an estimated 981,000 young people aged 16 to 24 who are currently classed as Neet.

Without any intervention, the Youth Futures Foundation – a non-profit which aims to improve youth employment outlooks in the UK – estimates there could be more than a million by the end of 2036.

How each policy would reduce Neets

Against that backdrop, Milburn’s plans would aim to reduce the number of Neets by around half, based on the projected 500,000 increase in those in education, employment or training.

Analysts working on the Milburn report have compiled the figure by assessing how much each policy – from employment offers to mental health support – would reduce the Neet rate by over the next 10 years.

Milburn’s proposals would, he believes, take the UK from having one of the highest Neet rates in Europe – at 13.6 per cent – to one of the lowest. It is hoped the reforms would bring the Neet rate in Britain on par with countries like the Netherlands, with just 4.8 per cent of Neets, and Denmark, with a rate of around 8 per cent.

His plans are also forecast to lift 50,000 people out of relative poverty over the 10-year period, with the projected increase in youth employment expected to contribute to higher household incomes.

This stands in contrast to Starmer’s botched benefit cuts, forecast push 250,000 people into poverty, which were abandoned amid a rebellion by Labour backbenchers. 

Former welfare rebel Daniel Francis MP – who rebelled against Starmer’s reforms as the father of a disabled daughter – told The i Paper he is now coming round to the reforms.

He said: “The aim should be to protect those with the severest needs but support our young people into work and make sure working is more beneficial than not working.”

Welfare rebellion still possible for Burnham

However, several other Labour backbenchers have voiced concerns about an overhaul that cuts benefits for existing claimants, raising the possibility of a welfare rebellion in Burnham’s future.

Neil Duncan Jordan, the left-wing Labour MP for Poole who temporarily lost the whip after voting against Starmer’s reforms, wrote to the Government saying he would not support reforms that would “make disabled people poorer”.

Brian Leishman, Labour MP for Alloa and Grangemouth, recently told The i Paper that he has “huge reservations” following a report in that the reforms would limit young people’s access to disability and sickness benefits.

Bell Ribeiro-Addy, the Labour MP for Clapham and Brixton Hill, told the BBC last week she was unsure whether she could support the proposals without greater clarity over their impact.

Andy Burnham has insisted the Government will not bring the welfare bill down by “crude cuts”, warning that simply reducing people’s payments risks pushing them into crisis and shifting costs elsewhere in the public sector.

But Milburn told the BBC there will be some young people who “lose out” on benefits under the overhaul, with less money spent on welfare payments overall and more cash invested into work opportunities.

Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) Secretary Pat McFadden also said that some existing claimants will lose their benefits when their claims are reassessed under the new system.

The review will lay out a 10-year plan for getting young people off benefits and into work which is expected to be implemented by the Government.

The entire welfare bill – which includes disability benefits, universal credit and the state pension – is expected to increase from £333bn in 2025/26 to £431bn in 2030/31.

By Daniel Francis, MP for Bexleyheath and Crayford

I have 13 year old twins and one of them has significant additional needs. My daughter was born prematurely with quadriplegic cerebral palsy.

Every day, my wife and I change her nappies, dress her, feed her, lift her between her seating equipment, bathe her – basically support her to do everything. She will never work a day in her life. When my other daughter is older and enters the workplace, I know she’ll be contributing to the safety net which protects her twin sister.

This is why I found last year’s welfare debate so difficult. I am not a natural rebel. But I felt forced to oppose changes which I believed would be detrimental to disabled people.

My experience as a carer has also allowed me to see first hand how disabled people – and those around them – can end up not working because of the current disincentives in the system. In our case, my council sent a social worker to our house who told my wife and I that we would be better off giving up our jobs, becoming full time carers and living on universal credit. That’s not the right approach.

The Tories failed disabled people – and particularly our young people – and it is incumbent on this Labour Government to build a system that works for them. These issues cannot be resolved by the DWP alone – they require a whole system approach which is what I’m pleased is being recognised now.

Like colleagues, I am waiting to see the Milburn Report in full when it is published this week, but I am grateful for the consultation undertaken by Alan and by the DWP Secretary of State and Ministers over the last year.

They’ve heard me consistently say we must have a system which protects the most severely disabled but supports those young people that can work. A system which gives hope again not just to them, but to their parents and grandparents about the kind of country we aspire to be. 

I’ve always said I believe the welfare bill needs to come down and I will support this. The aim should be to protect those with the severest needs while supporting our young people into work. I believe we’ve learned the lessons from last year’s welfare debate and this time I’m hopeful I will be able to support these proposals. 

Original source Benefits overhaul would halve number of Neets in a decade

Back to home