Bruno Guimaraes deserves to be booed by Newcastle fans

Bruno Guimarães was a truly great captain of Newcastle United, a history breaker and a standard setter over four superb years.

But none of that will save him at St James’ Park this weekend, when he will walk into the wall of opprobrium he has been trying to dodge with a carefully curated post-exit strategy.

It is not new for Arsenal’s trips north to be coated with a lick of spite. Perhaps on previous visits the tension came because Newcastle were snapping at Arsenal’s toes, one recent win drawing out Eddie Howe’s infamous “we’re here to compete, not to make friends” quote.

This time, though, much of the malice – at least before kick off – will be trained on Guimarães, who left Newcastle in the summer after pushing hard for a move to Arsenal.

FILE PHOTO: Soccer Football - Carabao Cup - Final - Liverpool v Newcastle United - Wembley Stadium, London, Britain - March 16, 2025 Newcastle United's Bruno Guimaraes celebrates with the trophy after winning the Carabao Cup REUTERS/David Klein EDITORIAL USE ONLY. NO USE WITH UNAUTHORIZED AUDIO, VIDEO, DATA, FIXTURE LISTS, CLUB/LEAGUE LOGOS OR 'LIVE' SERVICES. ONLINE IN-MATCH USE LIMITED TO 120 IMAGES, NO VIDEO EMULATION. NO USE IN BETTING, GAMES OR SINGLE CLUB/LEAGUE/PLAYER PUBLICATIONS. PLEASE CONTACT YOUR ACCOUNT REPRESENTATIVE FOR FURTHER DETAILS../File Photo

The Magpies are no longer genuine rivals on-the-pitch, picked apart by a combination of suffocating financial rules designed to keep them at bay and poor recruitment that has undermined progress. But there has also been some cynical maneouvering that hasn’t helped – and Guimarães will become the latest player after Alexander Isak and Sandro Tonali to hear how that is regarded by Newcastle supporters.

Since leaving, Guimarães has spoken of his love for the Magpies and he undoubtedly played with commitment and desire over five memorable seasons. He poured his heart and soul into the club and Newcastle made grand strides when he was wearing black and white. The decision to hand him the captain’s armband was a reflection of his passion for the club, as well as a clever bargaining chip to try and quell his discontent at not moving on in 2024 – and it worked. He lifted a trophy and captained Newcastle in the Champions League.

But his genuine affection for the club is not a protection against the way he left or the timing of his departure – and it does not mean supporters are entitled to embrace him or accept his attempt to re-write history about what really happened this summer.

In North London they will read this while rolling their eyes, no doubt. There is a food chain in football, we are reminded, and Newcastle’s position is below Arsenal’s. The evidence suggests that is correct, even if a set of arbitrary UEFA and Premier League financial rules are largely responsible for clubs like the Gunners not having to worry too much about the prospect of insurgents like Newcastle competing with them consistently.

Supporters are not obliged to accept this so-called “natural order”, even if at times it feels like the club have. At the time of his departure, Newcastle opted for the classy route of thanking Guimarães for his service and making it clear that he left with their best wishes. He made a token trip to La Manga to prove that he was not in breach of his contract and we are told there were tears when he addressed his teammates.

But do supporters have to show the same acceptance about the club captain pushing for a move when the club’s other top talents are moving on? No they don’t. They are entitled to still feel aggrieved at the way Guimarães engineered the move, leaving the club with little choice but to cash in. It was not a good way to leave.

Read more

The Arsenal midfielder will return to play a Newcastle still deep in the midst of a transition campaign. No one is sure how it will play out, but the next four games are absolutely huge for Matthias Jaissle.

The German is understood to feel that at times Newcastle’s players looked at Guimarães as their escape route. When things were going wrong their default was to play him the ball and hope he could progress them out of trouble. Re-modelling their game to play a different way has proved tougher than expected.

Newcastle wanted Guimarães for another year, perhaps to enable the fabulous talent of Sean Steur to flourish under his tutelage. The Brazilian did not agree and moved on, which was his right. But when he took that decision, his place in the club’s history was tarnished. No amount of love bombing after the event is going to change that.

Original source Bruno Guimaraes deserves to be booed by Newcastle fans

Back to home