I tried to pay £1.80 to park at a retail park, but the coin slot was jammed. I attempted to pay by credit card, but wasn't sure if the payment went through as it didn’t print a receipt. I felt I had done what I could to try to pay but, having failed through no fault of my own, I carried on with my shopping. I have received a parking charge notice for £100 or £60 if paid within 14 days. Is this fair? What can I do?
R.W. by email.
You have a good argument for challenging this charge, and I would certainly appeal before considering payment. First, this is a private parking charge, not a fine in the criminal sense. It is essentially a claim that you breached the contractual terms governing the car park.
There is also an important development in your favour. The Government’s new Private Parking Code of Practice, which was laid before Parliament last month, specifically addresses faulty payment machines.
It requires parking operators to explain clearly what motorists should do when payment equipment is unavailable, including whether alternative payment methods are available and whether motorists must leave if they cannot pay.
Crucially, the code’s Appeals Charter says that a parking charge should be cancelled where payment machines are out of operation and no reasonable alternative payment method is available. That is potentially very significant in your case.

The Government’s new Private Parking Code of Practice, which was laid before Parliament last month, specifically addresses faulty payment machines
You had made reasonable efforts to pay, and you should not be penalised if the operator’s equipment prevented you from doing so and no reasonable alternative was available. First, check your credit card statement to establish whether the £1.80 was debited. Write to the parking operator.
Explain what happened, provide any evidence and ask them to investigate the machine’s payment records and maintenance logs. Also ask them to identify what alternative payment arrangements were available and what their signage instructed motorists to do when machines failed.
If the operator rejects your appeal, you can take it to the independent appeals service: POPLA if the operator belongs to the BPA, or the IAS if it belongs to the IPC. I would also draw the operator’s attention expressly to clauses 6.1 and 19 of the new Government code of practice.
Before the new Code, there was no hard-and-fast rule that a broken or jammed machine automatically wiped out the charge.
The onus sat with the driver to take reasonable steps and prove it, retry the machine, look for another, try paying by phone or online, or contact the operator using the number on the signage.
A challenge then rested on general contract fairness and the operator’s trade-association code, rather than any rule obliging them to cancel. By contrast, we now have an automatic right for the ticket to be cancelled in these circumstances.
The new rules are not retrospective, so anyone who received the a parking charge before they were in place is still governed by the old system.
Screeching London Underground trains on my commute are so loud it gives me headaches and I fear it’s damaging my hearing. Do I have any rights?
Name and address supplied
The noise on parts of the Underground can be genuinely punishing, and there is published evidence that some passengers are exposed to very high noise levels. A study published in 2020 found that noise levels on the Underground regularly exceeded 80 decibels, with some readings above 100 decibels. However, it is important to distinguish between noise that is unpleasant and noise that is likely to cause hearing damage. The length and frequency of exposure are important factors.
As a passenger, you do not have the same protections as a Tube employee under the Control of Noise at Work Regulations 2005.
But that does not mean Transport for London (TfL) has no responsibilities. It must operate its services with reasonable care, and if excessive noise caused an identifiable injury because TfL had failed to take reasonable steps to address a foreseeable risk, there could potentially be grounds for a negligence claim. However, proving that would require medical and other supporting evidence. A headache or concern about possible future hearing damage would not, on its own, establish a claim.
First, if you are experiencing headaches or changes in your hearing, seek medical advice and consider having a hearing test.
Second, make a formal complaint to TfL. Identify the exact line and sections of track where the screeching occurs, and ask what noise measurements TfL has taken and what steps it is taking to reduce the problem. TfL has acknowledged that certain sections of track are noisy and can cause discomfort to passengers.
Third, consider using suitable noise-reducing earplugs on particularly noisy journeys, while ensuring you can still hear important announcements and remain aware of your surroundings.
Affiliate links: If you take out a product This is Money may earn a commission. These deals are chosen by our editorial team, as we think they are worth highlighting. This does not affect our editorial independence. Terms and conditions apply on all offers.