Concerns over £42m Senedd office block renovation as parliament's budget passed

Ty Hywel in Cardiff Bay - a red office block with windows in a grid pattern. There is a central glass atrium and flags outside.

Conservative and Reform Members of the Senedd (MSs) have raised concerns about plans to renovate the parliament's office block.

MSs passed the Welsh Parliament's £109m budget for 2027-28 on Wednesday, despite opposition from the Tories and Reform UK, and abstentions from most Labour members.

Conservative MS Andrew RT Davies called the renovation plans, expected to cost £42m over three years, a "difficult sell" to voters.

Reform's Cai Parry-Jones has criticised the plans, telling the BBC the proposed expansion of the office block, Tŷ Hywel, was unnecessary.

Commissioner Peredur Owen Griffiths told the Senedd the institution would seek to ensure value for money from the renovation.

Only Plaid Cymru fully supported the budget as a group.

It includes funding set aside for the Bay 32 renovation project, known as Bay 32.

The budget passed on Wednesday funds all of the Cardiff Bay parliament's operations.

In a debate on Wednesday, former Welsh Conservative leader Davies said he had concerns about the nearly 6.5% increase in the Senedd budget.

Davies complained about the number of staff employed by the commission: 523 full-time equivalent staff were employed in March 2026, up from 444 in the same month in 2018.

On Bay 32, Davies said: "At a time when hospitals, schools and other key projects are struggling for capital expenditure, I believe it's going to be quite a difficult sell, to say the least, when you're looking at promoting an office building in Cardiff Bay to receive such significant sums."

He acknowledged that doing nothing was "not an option", but said he had "grave concerns about the numbers".

Plaid Cymru's Elfed Williams backed the project.

"By doing nothing, we are merely kicking the problem into the long grass, and ultimately the Senedd will face significant repair costs for a building that is not fit for purpose," he said.

Labour's Huw Thomas said the budget's 6.4% growth was greater than the planned increase to the Welsh government's health or local government budgets, set separately. Most of his group abstained.

Griffiths, a Plaid Cymru MS and a member of the cross-party commission, told Davies he would work with him "to ensure that we do achieve value for money and the right decisions are made".

Reform was not present for the debate because of its boycott of proceedings, but did vote.

Parry-Jones said in a statement later: "Having worked here for six months, it's clear the commission budget is packed full of waste."

An exterior picture of the Senedd building with its lights on in the early evening. It has distinctive contemporary architecture including a sweeping curved roof over the main entrance area.

The Senedd is planning a major refurbishment of Tŷ Hywel, the office block that is the base for the commission that runs the parliament, its politicians and their staff.

The lease on the building ends in 2032. The Senedd's preference is to stay in the same location, but in a refurbished building, while staff work in a neighbouring site until 2030.

Bay 32 is expected to cost the Senedd Commission £42m over the next three years. Building owner Equitix would invest around £50m.

According to a report by the Finance Committee, the preferred proposal would increase floor space by 25% to better meet the requirements of the Senedd, replace windows that have reached the end of their lifespan and make other improvements to the building.

A full business case is expected to go before the Senedd Commission in December.

Prior to the session, Parry-Jones criticised Bay 32, telling BBC Wales he was concerned the expansion was "not necessary, so why are taxpayers paying for that?"

He described the current space as "perfectly adequate".

"It's not particularly luxurious, but it is absolutely fine and it does the job," he said.

Parry-Jones said that without the expansion in the plans "he would struggle to find something to complain about".

The Senedd has not published details of what Tŷ Hywel could look like after the renovation, and the BBC has been told the plans have not been finalised.

A proposed building plan, seen by BBC Wales, includes a "grab-and-go" coffee area.

Parry-Jones said he was also told it may include a wellbeing area incorporating a gym, more space for bikes and fewer parking spaces for cars.

The Senedd has not denied the claims, although it was not clear what form any gym facility would take if it went ahead.

A Senedd Commission spokesperson said in response to Parry-Jones: "We cannot comment on an ongoing consultation, and a final decision has not yet been taken."

Parry-Jones said he learned many of these details at a staff meeting, which he has been criticised for attending.

BBC Wales was told the presence of Parry-Jones, and Reform MS Iain McIntosh, made it difficult for some commission staff to ask questions openly.

Parry-Jones said he would have had significantly less information about the project had he not attended.

"There's no other meeting I have been into that has provided me with that information," he said, when interviewed in October.

More top stories

Original source Concerns over £42m Senedd office block renovation as parliament's budget passed

Back to home