Councillors approve controversial harbour plans

Protesters gathered with signs outside of a building with a Cornwall council sign. There is smoke in front of the protesters with black barrels which have warning signs and say "dangerous chemicals". Protesters are wearing gas masks and holding a sign which says "Refuse the cruise".

Councillors have voted in favour of a multimillion-pound plan to redevelop a town's docks.

The proposals for Falmouth Docks in Cornwall would allow large vessels including cruise ships to dock there but opponents have voiced criticism about the potential impact on the environment.

Cornwall Council's Strategic Planning Committee approved the shoreside element of the £150m plans with seven votes in favour and three against. The dredging plans are to be considered separately.

About 100 protesters gathered outside County Hall in Truro ahead of the meeting with one describing the scheme as an "absolute environmental catastrophe", but those behind the plans said they would boost the economy.

Campaign group Stop the Dredge said it hoped its protest would "reflect the strength of feeling against the proposals".

Cornwall Wildlife Trust said the proposed dredging area covered about 232,500 sq metres (2,502,609 sq ft), equivalent to about 32 football pitches, but only 21 sediment core samples had so far been analysed.

The trust, along with fishermen and Stop the Dredge, also raised concerns about pollutants being introduced into the Carrick Roads, Fal Estuary and Falmouth Bay during dredging.

An aerial view of the docks and Falmouth showing parts of the harbour, the docks, boats and buildings.

Balaena said it welcomed Cornwall Council's decision to approve the dock redevelopment, subject to conditions.

It said its proposals would "modernise dock infrastructure" and strengthen Falmouth's ability to compete for new work while supporting its future as a thriving working port, including opportunities for floating offshore wind.

Simon Gillett, chief executive of Balaena Group, said: "Falmouth Docks supports skilled employment, apprenticeships and a network of local suppliers and businesses.

"Our ambition is to build on that contribution, giving future generations the opportunity to develop their skills and pursue rewarding maritime careers here in Cornwall."

He added it would work closely with Cornwall Council to address the conditions attached to the approval and strengthen its partnership with the community.

Balaena's application was brought before the planning committee by councillor Laurie Magowan due to "the potential impact of the prolonged construction activity on the local highways network and surrounding communities".

He said: "I appreciate improvement and reduction in the potential number of HGV movements has been addressed in the application and proposed conditions, but I feel this is still significant enough to be reviewed by the strategic planning committee."

Eight students stood in a row. They are all holding signs. They are each wearing glasses with say "AT WHAT COST". 
Behind them is a building with large glass windows.

Along with allowing larger vessels to use the docks, the project also includes creating a new area for putting together floating offshore wind turbines.

Those backing the plans hoped the redevelopment would double the cargo and freight capacity at the docks and generate about £13m for the local economy.

The meeting focused on shoreside construction including demolition of on-site buildings, partial demolition of existing wharf structures and construction of new wharf structures.

A separate marine licence application is seeking consent for proposed works that would take place in the sea and outside Cornwall Council's jurisdiction, which include the contentious dredging.

Steph Clarke, an environmental humanities student at Falmouth University, was among the protesters.

She said her key message was "profit at what cost" and she did not think the developers' documents were "particularly thorough" and the scheme would "drastically change the fabric of the town".

Follow BBC Cornwall on X, Facebook and Instagram. Send your story ideas to spotlight@bbc.co.uk.

Related internet links

Original source Councillors approve controversial harbour plans

Back to home