Criticism after AI music used in UK's oldest carnival

Carnival cart with bright blue and red lights with the Gremlins sign on.

The use of artificial intelligence (AI) in music during the UK's oldest carnival is "disappointing", a carnival club member has said.

About 150,000 people descended on Bridgwater, Somerset, to watch the procession of illuminated carts, which showcase local creativity and talent.

Speaking after the event in Bridgwater, Matt Ward, a member of one of the smaller clubs, said it was disappointing that some of the 50 carts used AI music, adding: "We're kind of forgetting where carnival came from."

Organisers of the Bridgwater Guy Fawkes Carnival said they appreciated AI-generated music "divided opinions", but it is the individual clubs' decision, adding that carnival has "always embraced new technology".

More from Somerset

Ward said while new technology can save money and time, it feels like "the humans are getting forgotten about".

"My understanding is that it reduces the cost for the committees which I completely understand because the events industry is getting so expensive now.

"But it sort of felt like the whole spirit of carnival of bringing people together, celebrating people's talents and skills, putting these incredible carts together and performing.

"The music kind of feels like an afterthought, like, 'well, we don't need someone to do that, we can just put a prompt into a computer and have it generated for us'."

'Divisive'

Tim Bonser helped Gremlins produce its AI song.

"As a musician it's quite exciting and it's also quite terrifying.

"I think you can look at it in both ways.

"We've had quite intense conversations about it and it is pretty divisive," he added.

Bonser added that he does not feel bad about using it, but he understands why others might.

"Any technological innovation, it brings absolute positives and absolute negatives."

"Time is money and carnival budgets are tight these days," he said.

Event organisers said that AI-generated music may divide opinion, particularly among those who value traditional music production and those views should be respected.

"However, we should also respect the decisions of the clubs themselves and recognise the tremendous amount of work that goes into every entry.

"Clubs should have the creative freedom to portray their chosen themes and presentations in whatever way they feel best reflects their vision.

"It would be a real shame if the positive achievements of our clubs and the wider carnival community were overshadowed by a debate about one particular aspect of their presentations keeping this wonderful tradition alive," they added.

Get in touch

Follow BBC Somerset on Facebook and X. Send your story ideas to us on email or via WhatsApp on 0800 313 4630.

Original source Criticism after AI music used in UK's oldest carnival

Back to home