
A disabled man says it is a "huge relief" after winning a High Court battle against a council's decision to remove his exemption from paying council tax.
Andy Mitchell, from Taunton, was "unlawfully discriminated" against when Somerset Council reduced his council tax support after he switched from Employment and Support Allowance to Universal Credit, despite no change in circumstances.
Mitchell said he hopes the ruling will ensure fair treatment, amid estimates that 4,000 disabled people in Somerset are paying council tax despite previously being exempt.
Council chiefs say following the ruling they are reviewing whether any other residents may have been affected.
In a judgment handed down on Thursday, the High Court found the council had discriminated against Mitchell because the "rules treat people who have identical needs differently simply based on the type of benefit they receive, without justification".
The ruling could have implications for similar council tax schemes operated by local authorities across England and Wales, Mitchell's lawyers say.
More from Somerset
Mitchell previously worked for a university in London, but he had to leave due to his deteriorating health.
"I brought this case because I believed that could not be right, and I am delighted that the court has agreed.
"When I was moved onto Universal Credit, I was told that my income would be protected and that I would not be worse off financially. Yet I suddenly found myself facing a council tax bill of more than £1,000 a year despite nothing changing.
"I know there are many other disabled benefit claimants who have experienced the same shock," he added.
The court ruled that the decision regarding Mitchell's council tax must be quashed and his council tax liability for 2025/26 reassessed.
Carolin Ott, who represented Mitchell for Leigh Day law firm, said the issues raised by the case are "not unique to Somerset".
Ott said: "Other local authorities operate schemes that take a similar approach and we expect this judgment to have significant implications beyond Somerset.
"We are already hearing from people across the country who believe they have been adversely affected by similar council tax reduction rules."
Next steps
Councillor Liz Leyshon, the council's lead for finance, said supporting residents in need always came first, but the matter had been complex.
"We believed we responded in the most appropriate way," she said.
"Our immediate priority is to address Mr Mitchell's case, ensure council tax reduction is being assessed lawfully and establish whether any other residents may be affected."
The ruling "raises important questions about how national decisions have impacted on local council tax reduction schemes across the country", she said.
"We are considering whether there are any aspects of the judgment which a higher court should be asked to look at.
"We will provide a further update, including clear information for residents, once we have established the appropriate next steps."
Get in touch
Follow BBC Somerset on Facebook and X. Send your story ideas to us on email or via WhatsApp on 0800 313 4630.