
A doctor who circumcised a seven-year-old boy without his father's consent can continue to practise as his actions do not amount to misconduct, a medical tribunal has determined.
Dr Balvinder Mehat circumcised the boy at a medical centre in Nottingham after his mother asked for the procedure to be carried out, without any knowledge of the father.
The mother was married to the father at the time but she had not named him on the birth certificate, and she also did not mention the father on a circumcision consent form she signed.
Mehat's barrister, Ghazan Mahmood, therefore argued that Mehat had been "misled" by the mother, and was not aware the boy's father also had parental responsibility.
In their determination on the facts, the Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service (MPTS) panel said: "The tribunal considered that Dr Mehat's evidence was credible and reliable, supported by contemporaneous documentation.
"The tribunal was satisfied that he had made enquiries about who had parental responsibility for Patient A and was told directly that Ms C [the mother] was the only one.
"She had signed the consent form, provided a birth certificate without a father's name and told Dr Mehat that she was not married."
In a statement to the BBC, Mehat said: "I am grateful to the MPTS for the fair and proportionate way they have dealt with my case and reviewed the evidence.
"The allegations against me were originally made in 2022, I am relieved that this case is now over and my name has been cleared.
"As a GP of many years I am and have always been dedicated to patient care."

The boy was circumcised at Bakersfield Medical Centre on 19 October 2022.
His parents had married in 2019 but were separated at the time of the circumcision, and the tribunal was told the mother wanted it done for "spiritual and cultural reasons".
British Medical Association and General Medical Council (GMC) guidance says doctors should gain consent from both parents.
However, in his evidence, Mehat said he had discussed parental responsibility with the mother on 17 October 2022, and she told him no-one else had parental responsibility.
The tribunal also considered a consent form which the mother signed, which stated: "All those with parental responsibility are aware of the procedure above to be carried out without any disagreement or disputes."
Ms C told the tribunal she had understood the content of the consent form but signed it anyway.
Allegation removed
The GMC investigated the case and referred Mehat to the MPTS hearing.
One of the allegations Mehat faced was that he had not included the boy in the decision-making process for the procedure.
However, Mehat's barrister submitted that there was no case to answer for this, because the GMC had not produced any evidence to support it.
The tribunal agreed and this allegation was therefore removed.
This was the fourth medical tribunal Mehat had faced.
In March 2019, he was suspended for one month when his fitness to practise was determined to be impaired, due to Nottingham City Council cautioning him for numerous offences in relation to rental properties he owned.
Then, in September 2019, he was suspended for one month because he circumcised a baby without his mother's consent.
Mehat's third tribunal was then in December 2024, when he was given a warning for making derogatory comments about Muslim patients.
Get in touch
Tell us which stories we should cover in Nottingham
Listen to BBC Radio Nottingham on Sounds and follow BBC Nottingham on Facebook, on X, or on Instagram. Send your story ideas to eastmidsnews@bbc.co.uk or via WhatsApp on 0808 100 2210.