Former first ministers 'disappointed' by PM's devolution calls rejection

Mark Drakeford speaking in the Senedd chamber. He is shown from the chest up, turned slightly to the right of the camera. He has short grey hair, is wearing rectangular glasses and a dark suit jacket, white shirt, and red tie.

Two former Labour first ministers have expressed their disappointment at the decision by the prime minister not to devolve further powers to the Senedd.

Mark Drakeford and Carwyn Jones were responding to the confirmation that control over policing and criminal justice, rail infrastructure and the crown estate would be retained at Westminster rather than passed on to Cardiff.

In a letter to First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth, Andy Burnham said he had not been persuaded by the case for further devolution in those areas.

Drakeford told Politics Wales: "I am disappointed by the letter. The prime minister talks a great deal about devolution and he understands it very well indeed in an English context.

"We are yet to get a proper sense across to him of why these things are so important to us in Wales."

Drakeford, who was Labour first minister from 2018 to 2024, said: "There is more we have to do to get him to focus on the reasons why Wales is different to a mayoralty in England and why the things that are on the list, that are Labour party policy in Wales, are things we are determined to go on pursuing."

Carwyn Jones, who was the Labour first minister from 2009 to 2019, said: "It will come as no surprise to you that I am disappointed.

"I don't know what it is meant to achieve, if I'm honest with you. We lost a bulk of people to Plaid Cymru.

"A lot of our Labour voters, this isn't going to help to get them back. So we need to double down. We need to work with our Westminster colleagues.

"We need to work in Wales on what is the Welsh offer for Welsh Labour, because at the moment we're squeezed between Plaid and Reform.

"Getting your voice heard is going to be difficult. I think we can do it but it's going to take some time."

Carwyn Jones leaning on a bannister inside the Senedd. He is wearing a dark suit with a checked blue shirt, and has grey hair and a short beard.

Andy Burnham's position is at odds with the current Welsh Labour leader Ken Skates, who reiterated his position at a party conference last weekend that policing and the Crown Estate should be devolved.

However, in his letter on Friday, Burnham said he was "not persuaded" by the case.

"The integrated England and Wales policing system is essential to maintaining interoperability, enabling seamless cross-border working and ensuring forces in Wales can draw on national and specialist capabilities," Burnham said.

On justice, Burnham said he "strongly believes" that the current devolution settlement enables Wales to "benefit from the resources, expertise and resilience" of a shared justice system.

He added: "Effective partnership working is therefore essential to improving outcomes for victims, reducing reoffending and building safer communities."

The Welsh secretary Stephen Kinnock has also told the BBC that he has had conversations with a number of very senior police officers in Wales who are "deeply opposed" to devolving policing.

The First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth has said he is "gobsmacked" by the decision.

That was echoed by the Plaid Cymru education minister Anna Brychan, who said: "We do not think it's unfair to ask for parity with Scotland and that we make our decisions here in Wales.

"It is one of those things where there was cut through with people in the election campaign.

"People know there is an unfairness around the railways. The right to make decisions here in Wales are what essentially could make a difference."

'Cultural hostility'

Meanwhile, a co-author of the Independent Commission on the Constitutional Future of Wales report, Prof Laura McAllister, told BBC Radio Wales' Sunday Supplement the rejection was "indefensible constitutionally".

The report made the case for justice, rail and Crown Estate powers to be devolved to Wales

McAllister, who is professor of governance at Cardiff University, claimed there was a "cultural hostility to devolving powers to Wales".

She said Burnham's letter to the first minister is "so light on evidence and so selective in the sources for that evidence, that it makes a mockery of the argument that the prime minister wasn't persuaded, because it's hard to be persuaded by evidence that is so one-sided".

More top stories

Original source Former first ministers 'disappointed' by PM's devolution calls rejection

Back to home