Andy Burnham and Ursula von der Leyen enjoyed a Brussels waffle for dessert following their fish and chip lunch at the landmark Brexit reset summit in Brussels on Friday.
Whether that was a deliberate joke by the chefs, or one of those amusing ironies that should be filed under “lost in translation”, it’s impossible to say.
But despite the significant agreements hailed by the Prime Minister and the European Commission President, nothing is going to happen until the thorny issues of cheaper tuition fees for EU students is settled.
It was always known that an agreement on lowering tuition fees for EU students was unlikely to be agreed on Friday. It will cause a row in the UK and remains leverage for our involvement in the protectionist “Made in Europe” trade scheme, which can’t be agreed until it is passed into EU law in March 2027.
As a senior Government source told The i Paper before the summit: “Made in Europe – that’s the priority. We want the strongest commitment on Friday, followed up with confirmation as they settle their legislative arrangements.”
What might have been surprising is that the implementation of all the other agreements such as youth mobility and cheaper imports won’t happen until a tuition fees deal is reached.
The atmosphere in Brussels, some said, was awkward, despite genuine warmth between Burnham and Von der Leyen. The UK delegation – which included several Cabinet ministers as well as Burnham – seemingly bounced into the tuition fee position over Thursday night.
Negotiations appeared to have wrapped up shortly before midnight on Thursday, with Burnham seemingly poised to hail a historic breakthrough. But the early-morning Brussels intervention changed the mood.
EU member states made it clear that the agreements would not be implemented until Britain resolved how much European students should pay to study at British universities.
The statement was adopted through a “silence procedure”, under which a proposal is approved unless a member state formally objects. Circulated late on Thursday night, it passed without objection by Friday morning.
As talks entered their final hours, one EU diplomat warned: “The Brits have to move if they want a deal.”
Both sides then sought to play down the suggestion that the entire reset could be held up, pointing to the six-month window they have given themselves to reach an agreement, well before the other arrangements are due to come into force.
But Britain is likely to have to reduce university fees for EU students, potentially at a cost of hundreds of millions of pounds.
Rwanda migrant plan back in sight
Yet, the most politically significant development may have come not on trade or student exchanges, but on migration.
At Friday’s summit, the UK and EU agreed to work more closely together on sharing information and intelligence to tackle irregular migration and the Channel crisis.
The new “structured dialogue” will cover people-smuggling networks, border management, co-operation with third countries and returns.
It is not a returns agreement, but could provide the framework for one. Some EU countries are understood to be open to a deal with Britain that could help tackle the small boats crisis, The i Paper understands.
And Burnham himself indicated he’d be open to a returns scheme to a third country, saying the UK was watching a Rwanda returns plan being hammered out by five EU nations. Asked about this on Friday he said ministers want to “get closer” to discussions “happening in Europe around third-country returns”.
“We would be interested in finding out where Europe is up to on that,” he told the press conference.
Britain’s pilot “one in, one out” agreement with France ended in September, with Paris having pushed for an EU-wide replacement. No such deal was agreed, leaving the UK without a mechanism to return asylum seekers crossing the Channel in small boats.
Some EU countries nevertheless believe a returns arrangement remains the “long-term direction of travel”, one source said.

One possible model would involve Britain accepting migrants from mainland Europe in return for being able to send back those arriving irregularly across the Channel, removing the incentive to make the dangerous journey.
Other sources cautioned that under such a deal “the UK will have to accept a lot of migrants”.
Greece, Italy, Spain and Malta, among the EU’s Mediterranean frontline states, are still struggling to agree Brussels’ migration pact, which would share responsibility for asylum seekers across the bloc.
An arrangement with Britain could prove impossible until the EU wins over its own sceptical members.
No more half-measures
While Burnham’s first big Brussels summit as Prime Minister was supposed to be about making Brexit work better it has, instead, exposed just how much bigger the question of Britain’s future relationship with Europe has become.
For Burnham, closer co-operation could offer a practical answer to one of Brexit’s most politically difficult consequences. But it raises a bigger question: how far does he actually want to take Britain back towards Europe?
Brussels has made it clear that no formal negotiations on a deeper relationship can begin until the Prime Minister decides what Britain wants.
Although, Burnham then said the next summit next year would see the Government “brainstorming” ideas with the EU for the future relationship between the UK and the bloc.
According to a source familiar with the discussions, the EU has repeatedly ruled out “halfway-house” arrangements modelled on Norway or Switzerland, leaving four options: retain the current arrangements, join a customs union, join the single market or seek full membership.
“He cannot turn up to the restaurant and ask the chef to make him something off-menu,” the source said.
Each option carries political and economic risks. Single-market membership would face resistance from parts of the financial services sector, while a customs union could put Britain’s existing trade deals with countries outside the EU at risk.
The source suggested neither option appeared particularly attractive to Burnham, who may ultimately favour full EU membership.
But he would first have to convince his Cabinet and parliamentary party that the compromises some favour are simply not available.
The Prime Minister is expected to set out his position in a major speech in December, although it remains unclear whether he will have settled the question by then. He had originally said he would lay out his ideas “around the time” of this summit.
Some MPs and ministers believe the Government should move cautiously, arguing voters have little appetite for reopening the Brexit debate. Others believe closer alignment is essential to improving the economy and that the current piecemeal approach will leave Britain paying the price of remaining outside the EU.
Stella Creasy MP, chair of the Labour Movement for Europe, told The i Paper: “This summit is a first step towards escaping the madness of hard Brexit.
“Farage and his gang have finally admitted Brexit is a mess but are still refusing to do the things needed to fix it.”
Naomi Smith, CEO of Best for Britain, said Burnham must “build on the bold leadership he has shown so far” and take the “essential and laudable step towards restoring our EU membership”, which she said a majority of voters across Great Britain now demanded.
But Oliver Lewis, chairman of Stay Out, called the summit a “humiliating spectacle”, accusing Brussels of exploiting Burnham’s eagerness for a deal and demanding British taxpayers subsidise cheaper fees for EU students.
One thing is for sure: Burnham has let the genie out of the bottle. Forces on both sides of the debate are gathering. As The i Paper reported on Friday, Rachel Reeves and a host of other big hitting Remainers – now Rejoiners – met on Wednesday to discuss strategy.
And Nigel Farage, the architect and mastermind of Brexit, is not going to see his life’s work undone. He was in Brussels on Friday as well, warning he would fight any attempt to overturn Brexit, and claiming Burnham has no mandate for his EU plans.
“The biggest democratic exercise ever in the history of the United Kingdom has just been overturned, or at least the process started, by a man with 25,000 votes. It is utterly shameful in every regard,” he said.
“This is not a fight that I’ve picked, but it’s a fight that he’s picked.”