In the summer of 2023, Clara’s* job in media was already stressful, but it started to become increasingly unsustainable. Her manager was signed off sick and Clara, 34, was told to take on her duties. To make matters worse, all of this was happening two weeks before Clara’s wedding. “I remember saying to the head of the team: ‘You can’t do this to me, not so close to my wedding’. I was super stressed and barely sleeping,” she says.
She had no choice but to take on her manager’s work and when she returned after getting married, Clara was told her manager was being made redundant. “It was a huge shock, and I realised I would be expected to continue to manage her workload,” she says.
With this in mind, Clara emailed her managers and HR, asking for a title change and a pay rise but they said no. “I kept being told that they saw it as an opportunity for growth for me,” she says. “It was quite convenient that they wouldn’t have to pay me for that process of growth. I found it really patronising. I’d started in the company when I was quite junior, and I’d worked my way up. The idea of growth was insulting.”
A few weeks later, the team had a leaving lunch for another colleague, who Clara was now managing. At one point, she mentioned what her salary was. It was £2,000 more than Clara’s. “I froze. I was floored by it,” she says.
“I’d been asking for a pay increase and a title change to reflect the increase in work. I’d done late nights and worked my arse off. When I found out that news, it was the biggest blow not only to my emotional state but also to my confidence. I felt like such an idiot for presuming that the company was paying me more for being senior, but also that they clearly thought I wouldn’t find out.”
In a move that could help prevent similar situations, the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) has said that workers should have a legal right to know what their colleagues are earning, in order to tackle pay discrimination. The EHRC says that employers should be required to complete compulsory questionnaires, which would allow employees to request information about their colleagues’ salary, hours worked, bonuses, overtime and job description.
Michael Newman is a partner at Leigh Day who has worked on cases relating to equal pay for almost 20 years and believes that “pay transparency is one of the biggest root causes for why the gender pay gap remains so pronounced”. He welcomes the proposal from the EHRC. “It wouldn’t eradicate unequal pay, but I think it would help reduce the gender pay gap over time,” he says. According to figures from the Office for National Statistics (ONS), the gender pay gap in the UK was 6.8 per cent in April 2026 for full-time employment and 12.3 per cent among all employees, including part-time workers.
For Clara, her pay discrepancy in the wake of an incredibly stressful few months at work, all while planning her wedding, pushed her into burnout. She spoke to a manager to say she knew about the pay gap and they were apologetic. But over the weekend, she couldn’t stop crying. “It was one of the lowest times of my life. I’d worked so hard, and I was being taken for granted,” she says. She went to the GP on Monday as she’d been unable to sleep. “I was signed off for a month. I felt ashamed because I didn’t want it looking like I was being signed off to make a point. But I’d completely burnt out. It broke me psychologically and emotionally. I was put on medication for low mood.”
Halfway through her sick leave, Clara’s work contacted her about an “exciting” opportunity. “They changed my title and gave me a £10k pay increase. I’ll never know whether it was the same amount that my manager was on beforehand, but I don’t think it was,” says Clara. She stayed in that role for another 18 months before leaving, but now thinks she should have left when she found out about the salary discrepancy.
Most commonly, the equal pay claims that Newman deals with relate to men being paid more than women. “Many equal pay claims start when someone discovers what a colleague – usually a male colleague – is paid,” says Newman. A lack of transparency is common “across all private sector employers”, he says, but they are “more pronounced in sectors such as finance, where large discretionary bonuses are paid”. It’s less of an issue in the public sector as salaries are often public knowledge.
Maria*, 33, discovered a gender pay gap at the marketing company she joined. She had heard people refer to it as being run like an old boys’ club. “I noticed a pattern among the people I managed, where the majority of female hires were being paid less than their male counterparts,” she says.
She asked around to find out what other colleagues were earning and discovered that a male colleague was on £2k more than she was, despite her being more senior than him. “I was furious. Not only was I taking on more responsibility because I was at a higher level, but I was also carrying more of the stress and workload. And for what? To be paid less?” says Maria. “I raised it with a few people, but it was brushed off. I was made to feel like I was making more of an issue out of it than I needed to.”
Most of the senior leadership team at Maria’s company were men, and she felt that male colleagues were able to “build connections and find common ground” more easily. Eventually, she left to join another company, largely because of the pay issue.
Sometimes, these sorts of revelations can cause chaos throughout an entire team. At a work party, someone revealed that one of Zoe’s* colleagues was earning substantially more than all of them. “Everyone had had a few drinks. One person in our team had been given this information by a former manager who had left the company and it spread like wildfire. We were just grabbing people in our team and saying: ‘Have you heard this?’ Everyone was furious,” says Zoe, 40.
All the team members of this communications company are at a similar level of seniority, which has made the vast pay difference hard to stomach. “I hadn’t really thought about pay disparity before as I always think I’m being paid fairly for what I do,” says Zoe. “But to find out this guy was basically earning double was a kick in the teeth.”
Since then, there’s been a lot of hostility in the team. “It has caused so much resentment. Everyone wants him to be performing above and beyond, so if he turns up late or leaves early, people make snide remarks,” says Zoe.
While finding out that your colleagues are earning more than you can be shocking and leave you feeling frustrated, some have used this information to push for a pay rise. This is what happened to Becky Jackson, 47, who runs a wine tasting company called Legs Body Finish, but at the time, was working for a big UK charity.
Jackson asked her colleagues about their salaries after seeing roles advertised internally at her level but with a higher salary. She found out that they were on £7,000 more than her. “I felt sidelined and undervalued,” says Jackson. She took this information to her line manager – it turned out she was also being underpaid compared to her peers.
“The justification was that the other individuals manage budgets, and because my line manager and I worked in training and quality control, it was a different responsibility. But we petitioned and said you can’t not remunerate us as much as the other team members at the same level,” says Jackson. Eventually, they were successful. “When we got the pay rise, there was a huge sense of achievement. I felt proud that we had articulated the importance of our roles within the team and were paid properly for it.”
Colleagues learning about each other’s pay and being disgruntled is a “very common” issue, according to Sarah Ropek from The Fractional HR Department. “Some people think they are being helpful in sharing that information with their colleagues. It often happens when colleagues become friends and want to share in confidence, perhaps because they have a concern about pay being fair or they might share innocently assuming everyone is paid the same,” says Ropek, adding that it can also happen in social situations after a few drinks.

Currently, the main legislation in relation to pay transparency is “section 77 Equality Act 2010, which makes any term of a contract unenforceable if it prohibits or restricts someone from having discussions about pay with a colleague”, says Newman. “The weakness of this provision is that it only impacts the discussion about pay being had, it doesn’t say anything about whether the pay should be disclosed.”
If you discover that colleagues are earning more than you, start by trying to find out why, says Newman. “This can be done both through just asking the question of the employer, or possibly raising a grievance. They can also take legal advice about whether the pay difference is possibly unlawful,” he says. Ropek advises speaking to your manager first. “They should be able to explain the difference. If they can’t give a good answer, then HR or their manager’s manager would be the next step,” she says.
Newman believes there aren’t more conversations about pay in the workplace because it is “culturally seen as almost taboo, while probably not realising that the lack of transparency may contribute to there being a difference in pay that may be related to, say, sex or race”, he says.
This idea of it being a taboo topic resonates with Clara. “No one wants to talk about pay. I think sometimes companies encourage that silence, but it does nothing but make the situation worse for employees,” she says.
“No matter how hard you work for a company, and you convince yourself that it’ll pay off in the end, the company owes you nothing,” says Clara. “I’ve learnt my lesson the hard way. If you’re not receiving adequate pay or recognition for the work you’re doing, the only person it does a disservice to is yourself.”