
I find social class to be an invisible obstacle course I duck under and clamber over every day. Unless you’ve remained in exactly the same place all your life, with people who share your precise values, education and tastes, chances are you will also be an adept ducker and clamberer.
New research published by the London School of Economics has attempted to delineate these hidden gymnastics, asking how we sustain friendships across the many shades of privilege and social status that divide us. It’s an issue that’s been with me forever.
I spent my early years in east London; neither of my parents attended any higher education, and I went to a state comprehensive school where my friends were the children of postmen, cabbies, policemen and caretakers. In 1984, I received an offer to attend a prestigious university. My course was English literature, a non-vocational arts degree, at a time when only seven per cent of the population attended university. Unwittingly, I had entered the poshest bit of a really posh place. I am pretty sure I was the only non-selective state school student on my course that year.
Through the people I met there, I learned that not all coffee was instant, became comfortable saying “juxtaposition” in everyday conversation, and started to sit with my legs folded all the time. They also gave me an entry into the media world where I’ve made a fun and financially viable life for myself.
Working in magazines in the Nineties, I found that the lazy toff and the eager, hardworking commoner were useless clichés. People from madly wealthy backgrounds were among the most industrious and humble. Whatever was driving them was just as effective as my desperate fear of failure and being “sent back”. However, the invisible obstacle course of cross-class relationships has never gone away.
What the LSE study found, through 42 extensive interviews, was something they call “class diplomacy” – how we try to turn what could be uncomfortable chasms into bridgeable gaps. The authors, Professors Sam Friedman and Rose Butler, identified three approaches: joking, avoiding and confronting. So, if I’ve caught their gist correctly: laughing about your friend’s Dad’s Bentley; never mentioning the Bentley; or having a chat about a society in which only very few can have Bentleys.
This made me think about my network of friends and acquaintances and how we manage to overcome our backgrounds. There are cultural pinch points – places where my acquired middle-class manners run out. Holidays are one of my “tells”. Even though I’m comfortable saying “juxtaposition”, I still don’t want “adventure travel”, where you go somewhere completely unfamiliar and eat spleen. I don’t want to eat spleen – I secretly wish every meal was a variant of shepherd’s pie.
Equally, there are moments where my privilege makes me feel like I’m wearing a monocle and plus-fours in a branch of Nando’s. I have friends who have struggled to pay their rent, friends who have clawed their way into property ownership after years of saving. My career, combined interest rates and a different housing market have me writing this in my own warm, London property.
When an awkward class barrier reveals itself, I try not to pretend I’m something else. Affecting the manners or circumstances of someone more or less privileged is doomed but very tempting. I have met people so rich that even mentioning being unable to afford something is awkward because there is virtually nothing they cannot afford. “Did you stay at the Four Seasons?” they ask, innocently. And tactfully, you don’t fall to the floor helpless with laughter. Why shouldn’t they ask? How should they know? Why should they pretend?
Part of the honesty is self-deprecating humour. We laugh at ourselves, not each other. I have a self-mocking Ray Winstone/Danny Dyer combo voice I use when I catch myself slipping into some old east London habit. In turn, privately educated friends all do a good Boris Johnson/Winston Churchill when they need to deflate themselves.
The only people who really mock me for my east London roots are my considerably posher children. Now fully grown adults with careers and favourite cocktails of their own, they work with the fine scalpel that only close family can wield. When I ask for my steak medium-well or mutter some quasi-Cockney abuse about another driver, they cruelly track it back to another time and another place. I love this more than I can say.
The LSE study was prompted by earlier research that used vast amounts of Facebook data to suggest that cross-class relationships assist social mobility. Harvard economist Raj Chetty found that a child who plays on the same netball team as someone from a more privileged background may well enjoy better life chances.
This was my experience. The set of people I gained access to via university not only opened doors, they revealed doors I didn’t know existed. I still don’t ski, I can’t slide an oyster down my throat, and I will never, under any circumstances, ride a horse (too big, too sentient). But my cross-class relationships have enriched my life beyond measure.
My work as a writer and editor has been to understand how other people feel, what they want, what they fear, what will grab their attention. There is no Oldham van driver or Chelsea gallerist I cannot identify with. I can find my way past glottal stops and whinnying laughs because I’ve spent my life with all kinds of people, and that’s invaluable.
Now I’m old (62) I have learned that the Bentley your dad drives doesn’t make your divorce any easier, it will not help make a first day in a new job any less horrific, and it will not help you deal with illness or bereavement. The key to remaining friends with people from different places is remembering that being human is a cross-class affliction.