I’m a food editor – the seven tastiest tinned soups I’m stockpiling

Tis the season of cold and flu, of rainy days and dark nights; annual realities that can only be cheered up by a warm kitchen and a filling meal.

A bowl of soup is the obvious candidate on a chilly day, and since the government issued its stockpiling warning, we’ve been rushing to buy tinned soup. While Iceland said its sales of tinned food had increased by 40 per cent, Ocado said that some popular brands of soup had sold out entirely, such as Heinz and Baxters, though it restocks daily.

I admit that I haven’t relied on tinned soup for a while because I enjoy making my own. Soup recipes tend to be light on effort and abundant in reward, but you do need time to make a good soup, as well as fresh ingredients and electricity that we’ve been warned we might have to do without for a few days here and there.

As I began to consider expanding my store of long-life and non-perishable food at home, the possibilities of tinned soup have returned to my horizons, and my store cupboard. However, one thing that stood out while I was trying soups was that they didn’t keep me feeling full for very long. Although, as a warm food, soup feels initially filling and satisfying, I did need to add something for it to feel like a proper meal. For me, that usually means bread, spread generously with butter, and a large piece of cheese.

“A tin of soup can be a really convenient meal, especially when you’re stockpiling, but how filling and nutritious it is depends on what’s in it,” specialist dietitian Nichola Ludlam-Raine, author of How Not to Eat Ultra-Processed (Ebury, £16.99), tells me. “I wouldn’t assume every tin is a complete or especially filling meal on its own. A simple way to boost it is to add a source of protein and serve it with wholegrain bread.”

“Canning can reduce some heat-sensitive vitamins, but soup can still provide vegetables, fibre and other nutrients,” she continues. “Some smooth soups are quite low in protein and fibre, so having them with wholegrain bread and adding beans, lentils, cheese, egg or leftover chicken can make them more substantial.”

Here are some of the best long-life soups on offer. Just don’t forget to add extra fibre or protein if you have it.

£4.75/560g

When it comes to long-life soups, my favourite comes in a jar rather than a tin, and it’s the grandly-named M&S Collection Calabrian Mushroom and Truffle soup. For me, this is the height of instant treats served with little more than the best available bread. If there’s some yoghurt or soured cream around, I’ll load that onto the soup along with salt, pepper and a drizzle of olive oil.

I compared the “Best Before” dates of these jarred soups with tinned soups that I bought during the same week, and the jars all had as long or longer stamped on the packaging, lasting well into 2028. The range also includes tomato and basil, and butternut squash and sage.

Creamy and rich, this soup is far superior to the others I tasted.

£2.25/380g from Asda

I turned to Baxter’s soups next because this is the brand I most often bought from the corner shop at university, when eating soup rather than chips or baked beans felt incredibly grown up. I definitely considered it a complete meal. The Indian Spiced Cauliflower contains 4.1g of fibre and 4.4g of protein per tin.

This cauliflower soup is up there in my estimation with my longtime love, spicy parsnip. Although it’s slightly thinner in consistency than I generally prefer, especially in a homemade soup, the spicing is lively and, overall, it does what it says on the tin (sorry).

Priya Tew, specialist dietitian from Dietitian UK, warns that there’s little fibre or protein in a can of vegetable soup, and we should think of it as a vegetable side rather than a main course. “A tin of soup on its own is not enough for a meal as most of them do not provide enough protein, fibre and carbohydrates,” she says. “But this is easily rectified by adding a side or topping your soup.”

She also says you should eat the whole can rather than the half can suggested as a portion.“That is not enough for an actual meal, it would be a side.”

Tew suggests toppings of cheese, seeds, chopped up falafel or tofu or stirring in some houmous, beans or lentils. Or simply eat with a sandwich.

£1.10/400g

I enjoyed this soup thanks to the chunky bits: little pasta and borlotti beans. Overall, tinned soup can be a bit thin, so bulking it out makes it tastier. “This contains a mix of vegetables, pasta and borlotti beans, so it offers a more varied bowl than a smooth tomato soup,” explains Ludlam-Raine. “A labelled 200g serving provides 3.2g fibre and 4.2g protein, though it also contains 0.9g salt. It could make a light meal, or be made more substantial with extra beans or wholegrain bread.”

£1.64/400g

I wanted to explore the Heinz range past its beloved Cream of Tomato, and see if there were more substantial offerings. This lentil and bacon can contains 7g of fibre and 10.8g of protein per can, so is the closest to a rounded meal of all those I try, though it also contains 2.2g salt.

Heinz is experimenting with packaging, and this week launched a new range in a microwaveable pouch, which it is describing as made from “natural ingredients”. They have a shelf-life of 12 months (compared to 12-34 for Heinz tins). The Roasted Red Pepper & Tomato soup claims to be “high in fibre”, but I’m not so sure – it contains only 1.1g per 100g, or 3.9g for the full 350g pouch. Heinz tells me this means it hits the requirement to be labelled “high-fibre” (according to UK regulation, it has to have at least 3g of fibre per 100 kcal).

Still, it is easy to carry to work, though.

Aldi Specially Selected Butternut Squash & Sage

£1.29/400g

There’s no fibre and 2g of protein in a can of this, so think of it as a comfort blanket rather than a meal. It does bring some autumnal vibes, but could do with more actual squash content to improve the flavour.

60p/400g

I love this, mostly because it reminds me of the OG Heinz version, and I love the price. As with the Aldi squash soup, it’s not exemplary nutrition-wise, with 3.6g fibre and 4.8g protein per can, but it should cheer you up if the lights go out. Of all the soups that I try, tomato is the one that tastes best cold.

Campbell’s Condensed Cream of Mushroom

£1.50/295g from Tesco

We’ll end where we began, with mushroom soup, the iconic Campbell’s Condensed Cream of Mushroom soup. I didn’t love it, I’m afraid.

It’s good value for money because the “condensed” part means that you can double the volume with water or milk, but it does taste somewhat gloopy.

However, this gloopiness is what makes it a useful addition to your stockpile as a sauce. It is best known in the American Midwest as an ingredient in the region’s infamous tuna casserole, a pasta bake made with tinned tuna, pasta and condensed mushroom soup.

Original source I’m a food editor – the seven tastiest tinned soups I’m stockpiling

Back to home