When a concerned mum and dad finally uncovered childminder Amanda Mathewson’s criminal betrayal, their worst fears were realised. Driven by growing suspicions of neglect, they walked up to her house and pushed open the unlocked front door.
Room by room, a chilling reality unfolded: more than two dozen young children had been left entirely alone, abandoned to the risk of catastrophic harm.
Under a kitchen table, a distraught two-year-old cowered in tears. More children were tucked away in a utility room. Five primary-aged children were locked out in the garden. And upstairs a fresh horror – their own two tiny children shut inside a bedroom with a roomful of nine abandoned babies and toddlers.
As the appalled father descended the stairs carrying two little ones, Mathewson suddenly returned. The doorbell camera later showed she had been gone for more than 30 minutes for the second time that day.
The father, who cannot be named for legal reasons, said: ‘As Amanda walked back in the front door, she looked up at me and we locked eyes. I will never forget it, she looked like a child who had been caught in the act of doing something they knew they shouldn’t.’
‘I said to her, “What the hell, Amanda? How many laws have you broken here?”
‘Her soul just left her body. She realised her life as she knew it was over, she was caught, she was done.’

Earlier this month at Kirkcaldy Sheriff Court Amanda Mathewson, 55, was sentenced to two years in prison
Earlier this month at Kirkcaldy Sheriff Court Mathewson, 55, was sentenced to two years in prison after admitting willfully neglecting, abandoning and exposing children to potential unnecessary suffering or injury to their health.
On the day her lie unravelled – August 26, 2024 – 27 children were found in her Dunfermline home. Fifteen were under 12, ten under primary age and two were under one.
Mathewson was licensed to look after a maximum of eight children under 12, including no more than three under primary age and one under the age of one.
A child discovered on the day of her arrest was a girl with significant developmental disabilities who had previously experienced neglect. Two others were found strapped into prams.
After her arrest even Mathewson admitted: ‘God knows what could have happened to those kids.’
She pleaded guilty and has been imprisoned, but the families’ anxiety lingers and on their behalf a lawyer is now exploring legal action in a bid to stop such an outrage being repeated in the future.
The scale of those affected has been extraordinary, with more than 50 identified children across about 40 families having used Mathewson’s services during
the period of her charges from September 30, 2023, to August 27, 2024.
Young children who were in Mathewson’s care continue to endure night terrors and potential long-term trauma.
Parents are consumed by misplaced guilt and fear for the impact of psychological distress on their precious offspring.
The court heard that one child developed a heightened sense of responsibility for the safety of his younger siblings; another spoke of being strapped into a buggy for a long time and, when he tried to slip underneath the straps, they became caught around his neck. Another child had to release him.
One girl won’t come out of her bedroom without permission. Some children have become clingy and untrusting while parents have suffered psychologically and have given up jobs unable to trust their child’s safety with others.

Young children who were in Mathewson’s care continue to endure night terrors and potential long-term trauma
The parents know the repercussions of Mathewson’s actions may not be fully realised in their children for years to come.
The fallout extends beyond these families. The case has damaged public confidence in childminding and shattered trust in the official oversight that was meant to keep children safe yet allowed Mathewson’s deception to go undetected for almost a year.
It was only when the parents who uncovered her misdeeds realised their children weren’t with Mathewson on a school run that they entered her house while she went out.
Who knows how long her charade of deceit would have gone on had it not been for the interception of the parents?
Compounding the families’ anger, it was revealed an employee of the childminding watchdog the Care Inspectorate had been alerting Mathewson ahead of unannounced inspections.
Opportunities to catch her were missed more than once – including a complaint to the Care Inspectorate in June 2024, two months before Mathewson’s arrest, concerning a breach of the ratio of carers to children and a lack of proper monitoring of children upstairs. The watchdog failed to act upon the concerns.
Mathewson didn’t just neglect the children – she cynically exploited them as unwitting pawns in her twisted scheme, using those of primary age in caring roles and issuing instructions to kids for them to hide and stay quiet when parents or any adults came to the house.
Upstairs she kept babies and toddlers confined and one five-year-old girl eventually disclosed to her mother that Mathewson had her stationed at a bedroom door to stop the little ones wandering off.
The mother said: ‘My daughter was effectively in charge, making sure they stayed up there and stayed quiet.’ Another parent said her child had been left to change babies’ nappies and had to ‘sneak biscuits because they didn’t get to eat anything’.
Children of primary age were kept downstairs in the utility room, often with the door closed and with instructions not to emerge while parents were present. They would sit around on the floor playing with iPads and being fed crisps and doughnuts. Children as young as five were left to travel to and from school unsupervised and were made to wait in the garden if Mathewson was out.
The court heard that parents found children returning home desperately thirsty, with clothing remaining implausibly clean despite diary entries recording messy meals. Some said they had not received the food recorded and had instead been given biscuits or sweets.
Children came home with soiled nappies, dry faeces on their underwear or with sodden clothing after they had wet themselves. There were unexplained scratches or bite marks but no accident reports, the assumption being Mathewson wasn’t around to prevent incidents or explain how injuries had happened.

Amanda Mathewson (left) in Kirkcaldy before the childminder was jailed
Always Mathewson concocted a plausible excuse and the parents trusted her given she was considered a pillar of the community who had been a respected childminder for three decades.
Parents were further reassured by an unannounced Care Inspectorate inspection on Mathewson’s home about a year before her arrest which rated areas including care, learning and the setting as ‘very good’ – the second-highest level on the quality scale.
The report said children had been cared for in a ‘comfortable, welcoming and homely environment’ and were looked after ‘with warmth, kindness and a nurturing approach’.
Of course, it now appears Mathewson would have known the inspectors were coming and a legal case will argue the breach created or prolonged a foreseeable risk of harm to the children.
On the day Mathewson was sentenced Sheriff John MacRitchie placed great emphasis on the ‘wilful’ nature of her actions, condemning her neglect as a ‘gross abuse of a position of trust’.
Many of the parents considered her a friend, one comparing it to ‘winning the childcare lottery’ when her child was given a place. Word of mouth was the greatest recruiter for her services.
The lengths Mathewson went to in preserving her subterfuge were remarkable. Behind a cunningly planned facade of artifice she concealed her callous disregard for the children in her care.
False explanations were given to parents that other adults or childminders were in the house.
To mask the noise of all the children inside the house, when parents picked up their children Mathewson blasted loud music by the front door and she would make sure her charges were ready so the handover was quick. She was sure to hide the bags and shoes of excess children out of sight, fabricated daily journals to fake their activities and strictly required parents to text before arrival so she had time to shove children out of the way.
Mathewson orchestrated a system where parents were rarely in her house, telling them that since Covid she had been using a doorstep pick-up system that had worked well.
She added that children got upset when adults they didn’t know came into the house.
But one father said he was greeted with a very ordinary scene when he did pick up his children from inside her home.

Sheriff MacRitchie told her: ‘You knowingly created conditions in which injury, terror and neglect were obvious and foreseeable. You knew the risks and continued'
He said: ‘I would go into the kitchen dining room and there would be kids, including my daughter, playing with toys. We would say a few words and say our goodbyes and go. It just felt like any other childminder’s house.
‘It is now sickening to think that she must have had children in other rooms squirrelled away.’
The day of Mathewson’s arrest was no aberration. It was routine for her to leave large numbers of children with no adult supervision for hours on end.
She covered her tracks with sickening duplicity. At Christmas, she took three children to a church party and sent them home with photographs smiling with Santa.
For the other six children who had been left to fend for themselves, she staged a generic festive picture to fool their parents into thinking they had been on the outing.
She regularly singled out children to take with her while others were left behind. On one occasion she visited a fellow childminder with only three of eight children in her care, and on a two-hour fire-station visit she took three of 11.
On a woodland walk she took four of six children and on another day she took five to a park while eight were alone at her home.
Sheriff MacRitchie told her: ‘You knowingly created conditions in which injury, terror and neglect were obvious and foreseeable. You knew the risks and continued.’
It is hard to fathom how Mathewson could hold such utter indifference for the safety of vulnerable children but certainly a key motivation was greed.
Friends said Mathewson was often flush with cash. She had two cars: one for the youngsters and another she kept pristine and child-free.
When dining out, she was generous with the bill. She liked holidays, manicures and Botox, and her home was on desirable leafy Dunfermline street where properties average a sale price of £600,000.
Kim Leslie, a partner with Irwin Mitchell Scotland and an expert in personal injury and child abuse law, is now acting on behalf of a number of the families whose children were in Mathewson’s care.

Parents wait to go into court for sentencing verdict Amanda Mathewson
Ms Leslie has been instructed to explore pursuit of a civil action against the Care Inspectorate. She said: ‘It beggars belief that a failing of this magnitude could go unnoticed.
‘The families involved have found it extremely distressing and are desperate to ensure that no other family ever has to go through something like this.’
There are legal hurdles, since the Care Inspectorate as a public body doesn’t have a direct duty of care to the children. But the revelation that a member of the watchdog’s staff leaked confidential information to Mathewson could open a viable route for civil litigation.
Ms Leslie said: ‘That’s simply not good enough and it cannot be allowed to happen again. This is a fundamental breach of trust which, by the regulator’s own admission, completely compromised the efficacy of regulatory scrutiny. The parents want the Care Inspectorate to be held to account.’
The Care Inspectorate has called Mathewson’s criminality ‘shocking’ but refused to say whether it has yet identified Mathewson’s mole, who could still be working for it.
Following Mathewson’s conviction, the Care Inspectorate said it reviewed its internal operations and introduced updated inspection, complaints, and conflict-of-interest procedures.
A usual route for legal action would be through public liability insurance but one of Mathewson’s providers confirmed her policy was voided and would not say why.
Unlike car insurance, there is no central database for public liability cover, forcing lawyers to rely on Mathewson to disclose if she had any other such policies.
Parents took reassurance from the fact that childminders must hold insurance to be registered with the Care Inspectorate but when needed most, it appears that safety net has vanished.
Families want systemic loopholes closed, saying that despite the many government-funded child placements with Mathewson, no red flags were raised by the sudden spikes in child numbers which were clearly breaching her legal limits.
Ms Leslie said the impact of the case on families has been intolerable.
She added: ‘Mathewson was a master manipulator who was very seasoned and skilled at this deception. It is a parent’s worst nightmare.’