We’re all very quick to jump on the bandwagon: “Is that it for Jordan Pickford?”
By picking James Trafford against Spain, all Thomas Tuchel has done is shown his goalkeeper that he can’t rest on his laurels. It’s applied a little bit of pressure, to tell him he might not necessarily be the first name on the team sheet. There’s an obvious alternative – now Trafford just needs to do it consistently.
England have never had a contingency plan for when their No 1 goalkeeper isn’t available. They take a goalkeeper to a tournament with 80 or 90 caps, then you look at the two behind him and they haven’t got double figures between them. So I don’t disagree with what the manager is doing.
There are two types of players – those who like that pressure and the types who like having the knowledge they’re going to play. When I was England No 1, I played better when I was full of confidence. I didn’t like knowing somebody could take my place. If I had a bad game, I wanted enough credit in the bank to keep playing. Noni Madueke is the same at Arsenal. With Bukayo Saka out, he’s enjoying playing week in, week out and he’s becoming a better player for it.
With goalkeeping, you have to have a clear No 1. When David Raya first went to Arsenal and they already had Aaron Ramsdale, Mikel Arteta said he had two No 1s. That proved to be a complete fallacy, a complete lie. When you’ve got a No 1, that stays – and it was Raya.
Less than two years ago, we were talking about the plethora of young goalkeepers and the quality: Pickford, Dean Henderson, Sam Johnstone, Ramsdale, Nick Pope, Trafford, you could roll six names off your tongue. Now we’re talking about Pickford and Trafford. The rest have fallen by the wayside. Henderson will come back into contention when he’s fully fit.
Eighteen months ago, Ramsdale was firmly in the conversation. He’s talented enough to still be in it, but the clubs he’s picked haven’t worked out for him. They’ve completely isolated him at Southampton. He’s just gone off the radar.

Nick Pope’s another one who’s fallen off the face of the earth. He activated his year’s extension, then Newcastle brought in Lukas Hornicek and Pope is not playing.
As for Trafford, we’ve not seen the best of him yet. He’s 24 and he’s only just played more than a full season of Premier League games in total. The season Burnley went up, he got replaced for the last few games. He went to Manchester City expecting to play, then they signed Gianluigi Donnarumma. It was very mature of him to understand he needed to leave and to recognise he needed to join a club the size and stature of Leeds.
He made a mistake at Bournemouth and I watched his demeanour in the rest of that game. It didn’t affect him. I always compare it to a golfer. If you hit a bad shot in golf, the next one’s the most important. I remember Tiger Woods playing at the Masters. He took a 10 on a par 3. If that was me, the clubs are going in the water and I’m stomping off. He birdied the next hole – to have the mentality to be able to do that! You’re going to make mistakes as a goalkeeper – Trafford seems to have the mindset to deal with it.
As English goalkeepers, we haven’t had one quite in the bracket of Ederson, Alisson, Thibaut Courtois at their peaks. The bracket underneath, we’re flush with. Trafford has the potential to enter that top bracket, while Pickford has improved as a person and a player. There was a lot of talk about his antics on the pitch – he’s understood who he is, and he’s channelled the best part of him in the right way.
Read more
The biggest credit you can pay him is that the noise around him has gone away – until now, when Trafford has come in. All of a sudden, it’s “Jordan Pickford’s place is under threat”.
Why should it be? He’s done nothing wrong in an England jersey and he’s the most experienced option. He’s an excellent shot-stopper and his long distribution is first class.
At the moment, I don’t see there’s any need to replace Jordan. Without a doubt, the next major tournament he will be playing, but he’ll be 34. It just goes to show Tuchel sees this as a long-term project. He’s not in overnight thinking, how do I win the next game? He’s preparing for life further down the road – and life after Jordan Pickford.