Parents of disabled children fear losing much-needed income as the Government prepares to introduce plans for a radical welfare overhaul, in a bid to get more young people into work.
Alan Milburn, the Government’s youth unemployment adviser, wants to stop 16- to 24-year-olds getting the health element of universal credit or personal independence payments (PIP). Only the most severely disabled young people would get support under Milburn’s plans, set to be published on Tuesday.
Erika Lye is anxious about what Milburn’s plans means for her family. She and her husband are full-time carers for their two disabled sons in Neath Port Talbot, South Wales.
Jack, 17, is autistic and non-verbal, and Logan, 20, has cerebral palsy, learning difficulties and is autistic.
“There are just no opportunities there for Jack and Logan, their disabilities are so severe,” Lye told The i Paper. “It’s disconnected from reality, if the Government thinks that’s possible.”
Lye and her husband get around £1,200 in universal credit, which includes money to help them care for Jack, who at 17 is classed as a child.
As an adult, Logan gets £768 a month in universal credit – including £429 in the health element for those unable to work. This takes the family’s universal credit income to almost £1,970.
Young people would no longer be able to claim PIP under Milburn’s plans, with the Labour grandee to recommend that under-25s are moved to something called the “additional cost allowance”. Fewer people are likely to meet the criteria for this new allowance than those who currently claim PIP, according to reports.
Lye fears Government cuts could lead to a £956 drop in her family’s income – something they cannot afford.
She said it was a “365-day-a-year job caring for both the boys”, and that it is already a struggle to pay bills.
“The cost of living increases mean we can’t afford do much at all in terms of activities,” she said. “There’s nothing left over each month. I wish the Government understood what families were facing.”
Each month, the family pays around £750 towards their mortgage and £390 is spent on energy bills and fuel for their car. Another £500 to £600 goes towards other monthly bills.
The family also spend around £750 a month on food – plus another £50 to £100 on extra dietary supplements for their sons. They can spend anywhere from £100 to £300 on replacing clothes for Logan and Jack. Another £95 goes on myofascial release (MFR) therapy for Logan.
“There are so many extra costs,” she said. “There are extra costs to constantly replacing so much clothing that they tear through. It’s commercial-level amounts of washing.
“The boys tend break or damage so many things in the house, so there are constant replacement costs.”

‘Don’t see how we would keep our home’
Under Milburn’s plans, under-25s would no longer be eligible for the health element of universal credit, and instead receive a “youth allowance” – the same amount as the £338 basic rate of universal credit.
Lye is worried that Logan will lose his £429 a month in the universal credit health element.
She also worries that when Jack becomes an adult at 18, she and her husband will lose the £865 a month in universal credit aimed at helping them care for a disabled child. If Jack starts receiving the “youth allowance” that’s another £527 a month lost for the family.
If the universal credit health element is cut for under-25s – and no financial support is there to replace it – the family’s monthly income would fall by £956.
“If the health element was cut for them, it would be devastating. It’s a massive drop,” said Lye.
“There wouldn’t be enough money to pay bills and pay for the things they need,” she added. “I don’t see how we would be able to pay the mortgage and keep our home.”
Young people with the most profound disabilities, who are unable to work, could still qualify for a new benefit under Milburn’s plans. It will be paid at a higher rate than the current benefit, according to reports.
But it is not clear how exactly the Government would decide which young people have severe enough disabilities to be deemed unfit to work. The new benefit would be “much more targeted” on a “small cohort”, Milburn has said.
“I would hope their severe needs would be recognised,” said Lye on her two disabled sons. “But you can’t be sure of anything at the moment. There’s no reassurance in what he [Milburn] is recommending.”
Milburn has said his changes, if enacted, would not amount to “crude cuts”. He wants the Prime Minister to reinvest benefit money in stronger employment support for young people.
Charities have warned the changes could backfire by making it harder for some disabled young people to stay in work or training.
Una Summerson, head of policy for Contact, a charity for families with disabled children, said cutting the universal credit health element for under-25s “risks undermining the very opportunities the Government says it wants to improve”.
Disability minister Sir Stephen Timms recently revealed that 26 per cent of young people under 25 receiving the universal credit health element are already in education, training or employment.
A Department of Work and Pensions spokesperson said it “will always make sure the system is there for and supports those with the most severe conditions”. Upcoming reviews by Milburn and Timms, which examines PIP, “will lay the foundation for sustainable reform”, they added.