
A plan to overhaul benefits for young people could be used as a spring board to radically reshape the welfare system for millions, The i Paper understands.
The Labour grandee Alan Milburn published his long-awaited review into the problem of almost one million young people not in employment, education or training (Neets) on Tuesday.
Among the recommendations in the landmark plan, the former Labour health secretary suggested a overhaul of benefits for the under 25s – adding that the principles could also be applied to millions on benefits over this age.
A source familiar with the discussions has told The i Paper that ministers are looking at the possibility of a much wider overhaul of the benefits system – with the proposals in Milburn’s report potentially providing the blueprint for wider reform.
Milburn said the design of his proposed new system could be applied to older claimants.
“The over 25 year-old part of the welfare system has been beyond the remit of this review, but the design features of the system proposed here for young people could be applied to the older cohort of claimants,” he wrote.
He said the Government should “act with urgency” to bring forward proposals for a reformed welfare system for people aged 25 and over.
Asked whether the reforms could be extended to people aged over 25, the Prime Minister’s spokesman said ministers would consider the report alongside Sir Stephen Timms’s review of disability benefits – due to be published in the next few weeks – given the overlap in their recommendations on health, disability and benefit entitlement.
The ‘conundrum at the heart of all this’
He said the Government would respond to the recommendations of both reviews before the end of the year, with a white paper setting out its plans expected early next year.
Both reviews are part of attempts to reduce the benefits bill which is projected to cost £353bn this year, and to rise to £431bn by 2032.
A second Government source told The i Paper “Milburn was commissioned to look at young people specifically and has talked about the particular circumstances they face and the specific support offer that should be in place for them”.
They added: “Wider reforms of the benefit system have already begun – we cut the rate of sickness benefit for new claimants last year and have brought in a record £1bn of personalised employment support for people of all ages.
“Further reforms will follow the Timms review and be set out in the white paper next year.”
It is understood that Milburn and Timms have been “sharing openly” as they go, and while they are approaching the benefits system from two different perspectives, they “can’t help but intercept”.
Asked whether over 25s would be included in the legislation next year, Milburn told a press conference that is a “conundrum at the heart of all of this”, as while health and disability benefits costs are growing the fastest for younger people, more money is spent on the older cohort.
What is Milburn proposing?
It is understood that some within Government believe the proposals would ultimately prove too politically difficult to extend to older age groups, given the likely backlash to cuts within Labour.
Others believed Milburn had made the case for a fundamental change to the welfare system and that the public would support the approach.
Milburn is proposing a wholesale overhaul of the way the state supports young people – combining changes to benefits with new legal guarantees of jobs, education and training, alongside more help with mental health and disability.
He wants to replace the existing system for under-25s with a new, means-tested Youth Allowance, scrap the Work Capability Assessment and replace Personal Independence Payment (PIP) – the benefit designed to help disabled people meet the additional costs associated with their condition – with a new Additional Costs Allowance for young people with significant, ongoing disability-related costs.
Those with the most profound and long-term disabilities would qualify for a separate, more generous payment.
In return for the new support, young people claiming benefits would be expected to engage with their participation plans and take up reasonable offers of work or training.
This would include a named adviser, a personalised plan and help tackling barriers such as poor mental health, disability, housing and transport.
Sanctions would be rare
Young people would also be offered routes into paid work, apprenticeships, college courses, training and work placements. Those still out of work or education after 12 months of engaging with support would be guaranteed a paid six-month job.
Milburn says sanctions should be rare, but persistent refusal to engage could ultimately lead to the loss of Youth Allowance.
“As opportunities increase, so do obligations,” he told a press conference. “A young person who persistently refuses to engage can ultimately lose their benefits. Sanctions, of course, should be read and reviewed regularly, but a deal without consequences is not a deal.”
The reforms would be phased in over the next decade
By the end of this Parliament, he said he also expects the Government to have passed legislation outlining a “new benefits system.”