
Ministers are considering softening a proposed crackdown on zero-hours contracts following warnings that the reforms could make it harder for young people to find work.
The plans are in Angela Rayner’s Employment Rights Act, one of Labour’s flagship promises, billed as a major upgrade to workers’ rights and an end to insecurity for millions.
However, the provisions on zero hours have become a source of growing concern.
Alan Milburn, the former Labour health secretary who published his review into Neets – those not in employment, education or training – on Tuesday, urged ministers to proceed cautiously, over fears the changes could deter employers from hiring young people.
Labour’s original promise was to end exploitative zero-hours contracts, in which workers are not guaranteed a set number of hours, but are effectively on call and only paid for the hours they work.
Critics argue this can lead to the exploitation of workers who have fewer rights and an unstable income. But they are defended by others because of the flexibility they provide.
Zero-hours contracts are most heavily concentrated in industries such as hospitality, retail, social care and the arts.
The Government subsequently softened its original plan – into a right for workers to be offered guaranteed hours reflecting the work they regularly do, while retaining the option of remaining on zero-hours arrangements if they choose.
Milburn points to Government estimates that the proposals could cost businesses between £350m and £2.9bn a year, and research suggesting that 37 per cent of employers plan to reduce permanent recruitment because of the wider Employment Rights Act, which includes measures such as reducing the eligibility for unfair dismissal from two years to six months.
His intervention is the latest in a series of warnings about legislation championed by Rayner, the former deputy prime minister who returned to Cabinet in the summer when Andy Burnham become prime minister. She is now in charge of housing, communities and local government.
Allies of Rayner have rejected claims that the reforms would deter recruitment, arguing that the details were subject to consultation.
A roadmap, published by Rayner and then business secretary Jonathan Reynolds, in July 2025 set out a phased approach to implementation amid pressure to deliver Labour’s employment rights promises while giving businesses time to prepare. It also built in further consultation on the detail of the reforms, to shape its final policy position.
Ministers are now considering how far that right to be offered guaranteed hours should extend. A Government source familiar with the discussions told The i Paper it remained a “live issue”, but expected the reforms to be further diluted.
Officials at the Department for Business and Trade are looking at different ways the new rules could work in practice.
This includes deciding how many guaranteed hours someone must work before they are no longer considered to be on a zero-hours contract; how long they need to be putting in regular shifts before gaining extra rights; whether seasonal workers should be exempt; and what rules should apply to agency staff.
Under the Government’s preferred approach, employers would have to offer guaranteed-hours contracts to workers who regularly work somewhere between eight and 20 hours a week. Ministers are still consulting on where the cut-off should be set, with options ranging up to 48 hours.
Milburn’s intervention means ministers are likely to face a trade-off: set the threshold too low and employers may be less willing to hire; but set it too high and the reforms may do little to improve job security.
Those guaranteed fewer hours could qualify if they regularly work more than their contractual entitlement and meet other conditions.
The assessment also considers how many weeks of previous work should be taken into account when deciding whether someone has worked regular hours; what pattern of work should qualify; and whether certain types of employment should be treated differently.
For example, workers in seasonal, temporary or unpredictable roles may be exempt from the new rules.
These decisions could have a significant bearing on how many workers are ultimately affected.
The consultation has now closed, but the Government is yet to publish its response or confirm its final policy positions.
Burnham has signalled that ministers must be prepared to reconsider aspects of the reforms following Milburn’s warning. He said there was “a balance to be struck” between strengthening job security and encouraging recruitment.
However, he stopped short of backing Milburn’s call for a more cautious approach to the guaranteed-hours reforms in full or committing to legislative changes.
A Government spokesperson said: “We are committed to tackling the one-sided flexibility that can result from zero-hours and similar contracts, when workers bear all the financial risk of uncertain hours, shifts and earnings.
“We’re grateful for the many responses we received to our consultation. We are taking them fully into account and working to get the detail right so that the new rights work in the real world.”