The £300,000-a-week decision haunting Man City

The fact James Trafford was earning rave reviews for his heroics in an England shirt will only have sharpened the focus on Gianluigi Donnarumma’s form.

After all, the Italian’s arrival at Manchester City last year ruined any chance Trafford had of becoming the club’s No 1.

Trafford, 24, spent most of last season warming the bench despite returning to the club where he came through the youth system the summer before the campaign.

Then-boss Pep Guardiola wanted Donnarumma once he was alerted to his availability and believed the more experienced Italian would be a better fit.

Now, just over 12 months on, Trafford is excelling at Leeds United as well as for his national team, while Donnarumma is going through one of the worst runs of form of his career for both club and country.

This international break hasn’t been particularly friendly to him. Italy beat France 3-1, but the early goal conceded by Roberto Mancini’s men came from a misplaced pass by the goalkeeper, which Michael Olise pounced on.

Italy then conceded four in defeat by Belgium on Sunday night. Champions League winner Donnarumma – who reportedly earns close to £300,000 a week at City – returns to his club this week with serious doubts surrounding him.

At the moment, there does not seem to be a real threat that back-up Geronimo Rulli will take his place, but you have to wonder whether Trafford, if he were still at the club, would be pushing for a start.

Italy's goalkeeper #01 Gianluigi Donnarumma reacts at the end of the UEFA Nations League football match between Belgium and Italy at the Stade Baudoin in Brussels on November 15, 2026. (Photo by JOHN THYS / AFP via Getty Images)

Before the break, Donnarumma made a mistake in a 3-2 away victory against RB Leipzig in the Champions League, allowing Ridle Baku’s shot in at the near post after incorrectly anticipating a cross.

It came after he allowed Nicolas Jackson’s shot to go through him and hand Aston Villa a 2-1 win.

Against Paris Saint-Germain in the Champions League last month, he surrendered City’s momentum against the holders by failing to stop Maghnes Akliouche’s effort as Enzo Maresca’s side lost 4-2.

For a keeper with such a reputation and wage packet, it is not really good enough. Donnarumma knows that and is understood to be frustrated and annoyed.

Those close to the goalkeeper believe he has the character to bounce back and return to his best form.

There are issues, though. The spotlight is greater in the Premier League than he perhaps faced in Ligue 1 with PSG, who routinely won league games before preparing for big Champions League nights.

City have also conceded 13 goals in their opening 10 Premier League games. Not an awful record, but they have never reached that tally under Guardiola at this stage of a league season.

That is not all down to Donnarumma. City are adapting to a new manager for the first time in a decade and, while the defence has not had much work done, the midfield changed dramatically in the summer.

Donnarumma is also working with a new goalkeeping coach in Michele De Bernardin, who came in with Maresca in the summer.

One source suggested that “it is not the sole reason for his form” but is “maybe some mitigation”.
Donnarumma has family around him in Manchester. His brother Antonio, a close confidant, also regularly visits.

He is settled in Manchester, although he is still learning English and speaks it only at a basic level, something he is working to improve.

Maresca is understood not to be at the point of dropping him yet ahead of City’s home clash with Fulham this weekend, while those inside the club still believe the goalkeeper will rediscover his best and eradicate – or certainly reduce – the number of errors leading to goals.

Read more

They’ve invested heavily in Donnarumma. The pressure is now on him to show the money is still being spent on one of the world’s best keepers.

Otherwise the decision to move Trafford on may come back to haunt City.

Original source The £300,000-a-week decision haunting Man City

Back to home