The man Trump humiliated may yet inherit his party

Welcome to Power Players, The i Paper’s opinion series in which our writers and experts take an in-depth look at the key figures in American politics as the US reshapes itself and the world.

• The “swamp creature” eclipsing JD Vance in the race to succeed Trump
• Netanyahu’s to blame for his American nightmare – and it spells his doom
• The Democrat who has finally worked out how to beat Trump

It’s difficult to imagine now, but Ted Cruz once bested Donald Trump in a coveted political horse race.

It was a predictably frigid February in Iowa more than 10 years ago, and Cruz, a Republican junior senator from Texas, and darling of the right-wing Tea Party movement, earned roughly 6,000 more votes than Trump in the famed Iowa caucus: the first nominating contest of the presidential campaign season.

Trump claimed Cruz stole the election, intensifying a once-bitter feud. (In addition to implying that Cruz’s wife is unattractive, Trump also floated a conspiracy theory that Cruz’s father was involved in the Kennedy assassination.) But Cruz, just three years into his Senate career, had momentum.

That victory was supposed to be the start of a long string of wins, one that would culminate in Cruz sealing his spot on the Republican presidential ticket and going head-to-head with Hillary Clinton. Instead, he was felled by a monster of his own making: Trump ultimately trounced him in the majority of states, securing the GOP nomination and, eventually, Cruz’s endorsement.

In the years since, Cruz has been a faithful ally to the man who once denigrated his family and dubbed him “Lyin’ Ted”. The Texas Senator voted in line with Trump’s position about 92 per cent of the time during the President’s first term, and after Joe Biden won the 2020 election, Cruz objected to the certification of Arizona’s results. Further, while he initially referred to the January 6 Capitol riot as a “violent, terrorist attack”, he walked back those words – calling them “frankly dumb” – and supported Trump’s comeback bid in 2024.

After Democrat James Talarico beat Republican Ken Paxton in the midterms, Cruz is set to become the senior senator in Texas. He still wants to be president, though; on a recent podcast, he said “it’s no secret” he’s hungry for the White House. To get there, he’d have to best presumptive favorites JD Vance and Marco Rubio, while also navigating the caustic political environment his Tea Party politics helped create – the same environment he couldn’t hack a decade ago. He’d need to overcome a low approval rating for his work in Texas, woo voters who don’t seem to buy his purported support for the everyman and, perhaps most difficult, he’d need to earn some support among his Republican colleagues.

As the late Republican senator Lindsey Graham famously and brutally said: “If you killed Ted Cruz on the floor of the Senate, and the trial was in the Senate, nobody would convict you.”

Early in his career, Cruz was an advisor for George W Bush, whom he helped during the court battle that ultimately handed Bush the presidency in 2000. After that, Cruz became the GOP’s dream lawyer, arguing eight cases before the Supreme Court during his run as Texas solicitor general. As his successor later pointed out: “Ted Cruz was tireless in searching for every possible opportunity, not just to talk about, but to implement and execute, a conservative constitutional vision for the country.”

Cruz argued against a handgun ban; he argued in favor of the words “under God” in the pledge of allegiance. This conservative Christian pedigree positioned him perfectly for a Senate run during the early days of the Tea Party: the conservative movement born from hatred of president Barack Obama and “big government”. Cruz’s 2012 Senate victory was seen as a major upset.

Cruz also embodied the no-compromise ethos of the Tea Party, delivering a 21-hour speech on the Senate floor as part of his attempt to defund Obamacare (which remains intact today). In this way, he, and other candidates who rose to power on the backs of the Tea Party, paved the way for the era of Donald Trump.

Yet, it’s not clear what place Cruz has in the future of the Republican Party – a party he says needs to do some “soul searching” after Trump departs office.

The party has been consumed by manufactured culture wars and a toxic strand of Islamophobia that has its roots in Texas. Cruz, too, has been consumed.

He is a prolific podcaster who, in recent weeks, has focused on how Europe is “falling” because of its immigration policies and paid protestors. He echoes many Islamophobic talking points, too. Cruz recently convened a Senate hearing to claim Democrat Abdul El-Sayed, a Senator-elect in Michigan, is part of a Muslim Brotherhood plan to overtake the US. He also called him a “jihadist leprechaun” last month. Then, on the campaign trail for Kansas Senator Roger Marshall, he criticised Marshall’s opponent, Methodist minister and eventual victor Adam Hamilton, for a sermon in which Hamilton said people of all faiths can gain entry to Heaven.

“He says, ‘When we get to Heaven, there will be Muslims,’” Cruz said. “It’s an interesting idea. We show up there in Heaven, first thing you see is Osama bin Laden.”

These polemics have become commonplace for Cruz, even though they have no basis in reality.
“We are witnessing a new and dangerous red-green alliance,” Cruz recently told the crowd at a midterm convention Republicans organized in Dallas. “Communists and Islamists coming together and sweeping over the Democrat Party.”

“They hate Christians,” he later warned. “They hate Jews. They hate capitalism. They hate the Constitution. And they hate America.”

At the same time, Cruz has run afoul of far-right boosters like Tucker Carlson, who ridiculed Cruz on his podcast last year for appearing to know very little about Iran despite advocating for “regime change” in the country with which the US started a war.

Carlson has repeatedly criticized Israel and US support for prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu, thus creating a rift between himself and the White House. By splitting with Carlson – whom he now calls “the single most dangerous demagogue in this country” – Cruz seems to be aligning himself with the Trump administration. This illustrates the rock-and-hard-place situation the Texas Senator has created for himself: he seems to be on the outside of Trump’s inner circle and is also not fully accepted by the President’s critics or those furthest to the right on the political spectrum.

Based on polling conducted in late summer, Cruz’s presidential prospects are dismal compared to Vance and Rubio, whom most polls rank, in that order, as the most likely Republican presidential nominees for 2028. Vance and Cruz have taken some potshots at one another in recent months, with the Vice President telling a TV interview: “It’s really obvious to me, at this very moment, Ted Cruz is running for president”. Cruz fired back: “In my experience, people engage in political bomb-throwing when they’re feeling insecure.” For his part, President Trump has avoided indicating who he might favor, though he recently floated the idea of Vance and Rubio running for president and vice president, respectively. (He has also floated the idea of running for what would be his third term, something the US Constitution forbids.) When it comes to Cruz, Trump has joked about nominating the Texas Senator for the Supreme Court.

If he indeed runs, it’s unclear what a Cruz constituency would look like. The Tea Party label is defunct, absorbed by the “Make America Great Again” movement created by Trump. While Cruz retains strong favorability ratings among people who identify as conservative and deeply religious, his favorability among Black and Hispanic voters is dismal. (Making improvements with voters of colour between 2020 and 2024 was crucial to Trump’s second presidential victory, and a potential campaign rival like Rubio has consistently high favorability ratings among Hispanic voters – especially relative to his fellow Republicans). That said, both Rubio and Vance have the clear disadvantage of being key leaders in the second Trump administration, whose moves – including starting a war with Iran – have been widely credited with creating what Cruz called a “blue tsunami” of Democratic victories in this year’s midterms.

Cruz has spent much of the last decade trying to align himself with Trump, but in the immediate aftermath of the Democrats’ domination, he decried some of the President’s recent decisions.

“Tariffs have made everything too expensive,” Cruz said on his podcast. “And the Iran war has dragged on too long. It should have been brief, decisive and over.”

He has also reminded listeners on another podcast that he is now the only statewide elected Republican left in Texas – though he still has eyes on higher office.

“I will say, this is a bug that history has proved is rarely ended,” he said of his yearning for the White House. “It is a permanent and often fatal bug.”

Original source The man Trump humiliated may yet inherit his party

Back to home