The worrying questions for Pochettino’s nonsensical Man Utd

(Szoboszlai 10′, Wirtz 13′, Ngumoha 66′, Munoz 82′)

ANFIELD — On Sunday at Anfield, Liverpool’s home support chanted “Going down” towards the away end during the first half. During the second they added “…with the City”. It was deliberate, triumphant, gloating hyperbole. Keep making this many mistakes this often and they might just be right. 

By the full-time whistle, the away end was half empty and the rest of Anfield never wanted to leave. Why would you stay, to see something you love so much being repeatedly trodden into the dirt?

Mauricio Pochettino had come close to this job at least three times before finally landing it, so we can presume that he visualised how his opening day might go. Twenty minutes in and he was pointing at the pitch with the desperation of a zookeeper seeing the elephants and lions escaping their cages and the gift shop on fire. At least he knows what he is dealing with now.

The first quarter of the first match brought a scene of nonsensical chaos, a sea of individual mistakes forced by organisational dysfunction. Get that on a t-shirt – it could be the tagline of Manchester United’s last 15 years. 

We do not know exactly what the latest managerial lamb to the slaughter was thinking as Matthijs De Ligt dallied, Leny Yoro brainfaded and then Senne Lammens built a wall that acted more like a signpost. But Pochettino stood with the wry smile of a man who knows that he may see a lot of this gore.

Pochettino must take his share of the guilt. The execution of his plan was comically poor, but the plan itself lacked logic. United’s back three issues were laid bare repeatedly under Ruben Amorim and insufficient actors have changed since to make it work easily. It left huge spaces behind adventurous wing-backs who are hopeless at tracking back well enough to avoid calamity.

Even then, the personnel made no sense. De Ligt had not started a Premier League match since November 2025. He was rusty and hapless at the centre of the backline and that infected those around him. Harry Maguire was the only choice and was soon needed, thrown on after Yoro’s dismissal.

Thirdly, had Pochettino actually watched United’s midfield this season? A bad defence has been left entirely exposed to counter attacks and direct, dribbling wingers every time one competent runner is accompanied by Youri Tielemans (not a runner) and Bruno Fernandes (even less a runner, at least in terms of tracking back). 

So, what did Pochettino do? He started Kobbie Mainoo next to Tielemans with Fernandes ahead of them and then watched on as Liverpool swarmed. Well done, you’ve learned the same lesson every supporter did in August. 

United were fortunate to find Liverpool often profligate and largely half-paced. Anfield occasionally groaned and griped at their team’s inability to make a perilous situation humiliating. And they did that in the final 20 minutes anyway.

Soccer Football - Premier League - Liverpool v Manchester United - Anfield, Liverpool, Britain - November 22, 2026 Liverpool's Rio Ngumoha celebrates scoring their third goal with Virgil van Dijk and Alexander Isak REUTERS/Ian Hodgson EDITORIAL USE ONLY. NO USE WITH UNAUTHORIZED AUDIO, VIDEO, DATA, FIXTURE LISTS, CLUB/LEAGUE LOGOS OR 'LIVE' SERVICES. ONLINE IN-MATCH USE LIMITED TO 120 IMAGES, NO VIDEO EMULATION. NO USE IN BETTING, GAMES OR SINGLE CLUB/LEAGUE/PLAYER PUBLICATIONS. PLEASE CONTACT YOUR ACCOUNT REPRESENTATIVE FOR FURTHER DETAILS..

Is that any comfort for Pochettino? No. This was the opportunity to create an impression and set the tone, even after a precious few training sessions. That it was only the wastefulness of their hated rivals that avoided a cataclysmically heavy defeat, one to match the 7-0 of 2023, should be deeply embarrassing for the new manager. 

The nagging worry for United and Pochettino was twofold. His style of football, so successful and arresting half a decade ago, is no longer certain to be either. And it would be hard to find a squad in elite football that has proven itself to be less suited to pressing football and a defensive shape that requires constant concentration from central defenders. 

We are minded to think that this will get better, but we must also ask ourselves why. Is it because this team is functional? Is it because it contains the character to drag itself away from the edge? Is it because any of this makes tactical sense? Or is it just because we can’t believe something this big, this famous and this expensive will sink? Watch out for those icebergs this winter.

Original source The worrying questions for Pochettino’s nonsensical Man Utd

Back to home