This landmark genocide ruling creates a stark dilemma for the UK

When the inspectors came, the woman known to the court as NJ hid one of her children. She and her husband were Rohingya Muslims in western Myanmar. The authorities had made them sign a paper agreeing to have no more than two. If an official found the extra child, her husband could be fined or sent to jail.   

Later, soldiers arrived. They surrounded her village, Chut Pyin. They separated the men and boys from the women and small children. NJ said they beat her husband and her father-in-law and took them away. She never saw them again.  

Other witnesses described what happened. People were held in a rice paddy; the women made to kneel in one row and the men in another. Then the men were led away and the women heard gunfire. They saw bodies, or were told that the men were dead.   

While this was happening, soldiers took NJ’s child from her arms. The child was stabbed with a knife and thrown into a burning house. Then two soldiers beat NJ, stabbed her and raped her in her home, “one after another,” she said, until she lost consciousness.  

These events happened in 2017 in northern Rakhine State in Myanmar. NJ was among survivors giving evidence to the International Court of Justice at The Hague (ICJ). The UN’s highest court found that about 10,000 Rohingya were killed. By nine votes to six, the judges found Myanmar guilty of genocide – the first time in 80 years the court has made such a ruling against a state.   

This is not a new Nuremberg. There, in 1945-1946, the accused men sat in the dock and ten of them were hanged. The ICJ judges states, not people, and ordered Myanmar to punish those responsible. Myanmar’s President, Min Aung Hlaing, was the chief of the army in 2017, which means he has been told to investigate himself.  

Now Britain must come to its own view about whether there is a serious risk of genocide in Gaza, and act on it

But the ruling does change the law on genocide. It will be read closely in Israel, which faces the same charge in the same court – and in the capitals that supply Israel’s weapons.  

The Gaza genocide case will not be decided for years. Israel’s last written argument is not even due until May 2029. Today, however, the ICJ said that other states should not wait until there is definitive judgment on the issue of genocide. A government in a position to act in the face of a serious risk cannot “remain idle and gamble that the risk might not ultimately materialise”.  

This poses a dilemma for Britain. The Government’s position has long been that only a court can say whether a genocide is taking place. Now, in effect, Britain must come to its own view about whether there is a serious risk of genocide in Gaza, and act on it.   

And in the Rohingya case, Britain intervened along with five other countries to argue that the judges should not count deaths alone, but other acts by the security forces. Ministers may be asked why the argument they made for the Rohingya should not apply to the Palestinians.  

In Myanmar, the army said it was hunting insurgents who had attacked police posts. Its lawyers argued that the evidence could equally show the army wanted to drive the Rohingya out of the country, or to punish them: actions short of genocide. But the court found that the army intended to destroy the Rohingya. Soldiers fired on people as they fled, sank their boats and laid mines at border crossings.   

The court found that an intention to destroy a people can exist alongside other aims, such as defeating insurgents. However, the court may have blurred the line between genocide and ethnic cleansing. This could be important for Israel.

Yuval Shany, a professor of international law, told The Times of Israel the judgment “may muddy the waters” about what genocide is. The “uncertainty” could put the Israel Defence Forces at risk, even if they had observed the laws of war. Yonah Jeremy Bob wrote in the that the ruling “has made Israel’s defence of genocide allegations harder”. He pointed out that the judges trusted UN reports over those of the accused government, and held that a state can commit genocide while answering an attack on itself.  

This case was brought by The Gambia, a small West African country of three million people, thousands of miles from Myanmar. If the government of Myanmar does not take the action expected of it by the court, The Gambia could then go to the UN Security Council. But Russia and China, the generals’ main arms suppliers, have vetoes there. It is hard to see that meeting producing anything Min Aung Hlaing needs to worry about.   

More than a million Rohingya are still in the camps in Bangladesh. The court has told Myanmar to let them go home, to help families like NJ’s find their missing, and to punish the guilty. None of that may happen, at least immediately, but the court has given the Rohingya the word they want – and the judgment will reach into every other conflict where a people’s survival is at stake.  

Original source This landmark genocide ruling creates a stark dilemma for the UK

Back to home