Victim’s blood found on knife fetish website murder accused sent to friend

Victim’s blood found on knife fetish website murder accused sent to friend

Dwain Hall, 54, is currently on trial in Florida, US over the kidnap and murder of British woman Sonia Exelby.
Sonia Exelby, 32, had struggled with mental illness throughout her life (Family Handout/PA)
WEST END FINAL

A man accused of murdering a British woman he met on a fetish website told a friend there “might be a big storm coming for me” before sending him a package containing a knife later found to have the victim’s blood on it, a US court has heard.

The Florida trial of Dwain Hall, 54, was shown a series of Facebook messages exchanged between the defendant and Rick Snyder last October prior to the discovery of Sonia Exelby’s body in a shallow grave.

In them, Hall asks his friend for his address in Ohio.

In the exchanges, Hall refuses to go into detail saying “can’t tell you here. Lease (sic) I say the better”, and also indicated his phone “may be tapped”.

In a further message he said: “Might be a big storm coming for me”.

He then sent a picture of a UPS label showing he had sent a parcel to Mr Snyder.

Hall wrote in a message that he would need the contents back in six months “if this storm passes over with no lingering fallout”.

He said: “Please, for the love of shadows, don’t lose this box. There’s no need to even open it. These are very precious and valuable personal items.”

After Mr Snyder promised to keep it safe, Hall thanked him and told him to contact his wife, Ginger, about their return in six months “just in case this storm is as bad as expected”.

In subsequent messages the day before Ms Exelby’s body was found on October 17, Mr Snyder notes in a message that Hall is “jumpy”, to which the defendant says it was because the box contained “two of my most prized possessions”.

Mr Snyder wrote: “I get it. So how do I help you unf*** yourself out of whatever mess you are in?”

Prosecutors claim Dwain Hall, 54, is a sadistic predator (Florida Department of Law Enforcement/PA)

Hall replied: “I don’t know because I don’t know what kind of mess it is yet. For now, just hold on to the box. If anybody asked about the box that isn’t Ginger, it doesn’t exist.”

Confirming receipt of the package, Mr Snyder said it looked like a delivery from the major US retail chain Walmart.

In response, Hall wrote: “LOL, I know best way to secretly send something.”

Following the discovery of the messages on Hall’s phone and the UPS label, investigators travelled to Washington county in Ohio, where local detectives executed a search warrant at Mr Snyder’s property on November 4, 2025.

The contents of the package were found inside a cloth bag in the dresser of Mr Snyder’s bedroom, the court heard.

It included a knife in a sheath and a bracelet that belonged to Hall, the jury was told.

Giving evidence at the trial, a crime laboratory biologist said both Hall and Ms Exelby were “possible contributors” to a mixed DNA profile found on the bracelet.

Hall, Ms Exelby and Mr Snyder were also found to be “possible contributors” to DNA found the knife sheath, the court heard.

The jury was shown a picture of the black knife, which had “Dorkworf pointy end goes in the other guy” printed in capitals on the blade.

The criminal biologist told the trial she had removed the handle of the knife and found “reddish brown staining that did give chemical indications for the presence of blood”.

Asked why she had done this, she said it was because she had “information that this item may have been cleaned”.

She said: “I took a sample from the staining under the handle. I tested that for blood, it gave chemical indications for the presence of blood. I then took that forward for DNA testing.”

She said Hall was “excluded as the source” and then told the court: “The DNA profile matched the DNA profile from Sonia Exelby.”

The jury had previously heard from prosecutors that Hall was a predator who had manipulated his 32-year-old victim, who had struggled with mental illness, and then stabbed her to death “for his own sadistic pleasure”.

Ms Exelby, from Southsea, Portsmouth, who the court was told had a history of self harm and wanted to die, was reported missing from her home on October 12 last year, by which time police established she had left the country.

Her body was found by US investigators in Marion County, Florida, on October 17.

She had been stabbed four times in the left side, with wounds up to seven inches deep.

Hall was traced by police through the attempted use of Ms Exelby’s credit card by the roadside assistance company he owned.

He is currently on trial in Ocala for her kidnap and murder.

At the start of Thursday’s proceedings, the jury was shown data from the Life360 location sharing app, which prosecutors said tracked Hall’s movements over a number of days last October.

This included a time spent on October 12 at the burial site where Ms Exelby’s body was eventually found days later.

It also showed he had visited the Ocala branch of Lowe’s, a US DIY chain, earlier the same day, where he was seen on security camera footage buying a large tarpaulin.

The court has already heard Hall had bought a shovel and rope shortly before Ms Exelby’s arrival.

Giving evidence to the court, a clinical neuropsychologist described Ms Exelby’s level of vulnerability as “exceptionally high”.

Original source Victim’s blood found on knife fetish website murder accused sent to friend

Back to home