Why these shared-ownership property ads were banned – and what to look out for

Three adverts for shared ownership homes have been banned after failing to make clear the true cost of buying properties or who was eligible.

The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) upheld complaints against Guinness Homes, a housing association and provider, and property portal OnTheMarket.

They were caught promoting homes for between £49,375 and £107,500. But they failed to make clear that the prices covered only a share of the property, not full ownership.

The ASA also found that important costs, which can often be very high, including service charges, were missing. Some adverts failed to explain eligibility restrictions that could rule out potential buyers.

In one case, a two-bedroom bungalow was advertised as £107,500 on a 50 per cent shared ownership basis on OnTheMarket. The advert had quoted rent of £325.

The property’s actual monthly charge was £375.30 which included £249.09 rent, a £112.52 service charge and £13.70 for insurance.

Shared ownership, a government-backed scheme, allows people to purchase between 25 and 75 per cent of a property and pay rent on the rest, often “staircasing” upwards – in other words, purchasing a larger chunk of the home the longer they live there.

Residents, in this case, also had to be aged 55 or over and retired from full-time work to qualify – conditions that were not disclosed.

Previously The i Paper has reported how the shared ownership market has been struggling because buyers are wary of the quality of these homes, as well as costs that come with a part-buy, part-rent model of ownership. As a result, developers are now struggling to sell them.

In another case, homes at Latimer Fields in Crewe were advertised from £49,375. This covered a 25 per cent share. The listing included monthly rent of £339.45 but omitted the service charge and failed to explain that eligibility criteria applied.

The ASA also upheld a complaint against Guinness Homes over a property at Goddard Street in Crewe. It was advertised from £82,000, representing a 40 per cent share. But the original Facebook advert did not say this.

The share was disclosed further down the webpage. But it gave an estimated monthly cost of £718.34 without breaking down the mortgage, rent and service charge payments.

Guinness Homes and OnTheMarket argued that further details were available on their websites or would be provided during the buying process.

The ASA rejected this and said buyers should not have to search through multiple pages to find information that could affect their decision.

All three cases breached advertising rules on misleading omissions and the watchdog ordered that the adverts must not appear again in their current form.

Gemma Allwood, investigations executive at the ASA, said: “Important information shouldn’t be hidden away further down a website or left for consumers to discover later in the buying process.”

What experts say buyers should look out for under shared ownership

Shared ownership is seen as an easy and cheaper way for people to get on the property ladder – yet comes with many risks.

Owners can find themselves facing rising rents, higher service charge fees and difficulties selling.

Paula Higgins, chief executive of the consumer advice centre HomeOwners Alliance, said: “These ASA rulings are a wake-up call for the shared ownership sector, but worryingly, this isn’t the first time the ASA has ruled against misleading shared ownership advertising.

“Buying a home is one of the biggest financial commitments people make, and it’s unacceptable for properties to be advertised at attractive headline prices without clearly explaining that buyers are purchasing only a share of the home and will face additional costs.”

Higgins urged prospective buyers to check the full costs, how rent and service charges could rise and whether major works were planned.

She also advised using a conveyancer experienced in shared ownership to explain the costs of buying additional shares, known as staircasing, and any restrictions when selling.

Sam Richardson, money editor at Which?, said the ASA was right to intervene. “While it is frequently pitched as an easy, affordable route on to the property ladder, the financial reality of shared ownership can be far more complex.

“Prospective buyers need to factor in the combined weight of mortgage repayments, rent on the remaining share, and service charges before deciding whether shared ownership is the right path for them.

“If these commitments aren’t made clear, buyers risk stretching their budgets to breaking point or finding themselves trapped in a property that becomes difficult to afford or to sell on.”

Sue Phillips is the founder of the charity Shared Ownership Resources, which has long campaigned for shared ownership marketing campaigns to be transparent about potential risks and probable long-term costs.

Phillips said the charity continued to have concerns and wrote an open letter to the watchdog in 2023 calling for an independent review of shared ownership marketing, consultation on measures to prevent mis-selling and an enforceable code of practice.

She said: “Shared ownership rent is often described as ‘capped’ or ‘subsidised’. However, annual rent increases are linked to inflation which, of course, isn’t capped, leading to ‘rent burn’ for some households if they can’t afford to purchase the remaining shares in their home.

“Additionally, many shared owners report that service charges rise faster and higher than they expected, potentially undermining the affordability promise.

OnTheMarket declined to comment.

A Torus Homes spokesperson, whose home it was advertised on OnTheMarket, said: “The third-party adverts linked to our website where full details were prominent however we removed them once the ASA made us aware and have implemented its recommendations along with reviewing the role external companies play advertising our homes.

Original source Why these shared-ownership property ads were banned – and what to look out for

Back to home