Widow, 95, hit with £1,000,000 bill after 10-year fence row with millionaire neighbour

Champion News Service Ltd news@championnews.co.uk Tel: 07948286566 / 07914583378 Image shoes layout of dispute between Mary Egan and neighbours Neil and Fiona Morgan. PLEASE SEE SEPARATE CLEAN IMAGE FOR ADDING DESK'S OWN ANNOTATIONS

A 95-year-old widow is facing a £1,000,000 court bill after a 10-year battle in a historic Kent village over a garden fence.

Millionaire businessman Neil Morgan, 65, slammed a judge as ‘not fit to judge vegetables at a village fete’ and called a lawyer a ‘devious arse’ during a decade-long court fight with neighbour Mary Egan.

Ten years of ‘hostile litigation’ later, and with Mrs Egan having spent over £1m on lawyers after numerous court hearings, the row ended with both sides claiming victory.

But after declaring the result a ‘score draw,’ a county court judge ordered each side to pay their own legal costs, leaving Mrs Egan having to foot her own bill.

Sign up for all of the latest stories

Start your day informed with Metro's newsletter or get alerts the moment it happens.

Last week, the widow appealed, claiming she was the true winner and that the ‘deplorable’ conduct of her neighbour Mr Morgan justified her seven-figure bill being paid by them.

Champion News Service Ltd news@championnews.co.uk Tel: 07948286566 / 07914583378 Fiona and Neil Morgan outside High Court after hearing in dispute with neighbour Mary Egan

In a war of words, Mr Morgan had called a lawyer a ‘lying hypocritical devious arse’ and even termed his neighbour ‘malevolent’ and ‘all-knowing self-appointed royalty’ in case papers.

Yesterday, the High Court said that despite Mr Morgan’s ‘deplorable and unacceptable’ language ‘towards opposing lawyers and their staff…judges and court staff,’ he and his wife do not have to pay their neighbour’s costs.

Mr Justice Tappin said the row over a 60m-long sliver of grass, tree and scrub had resulted in ‘expenditure of time, cost and energy wholly out of proportion to the financial value of the area of land in dispute.’

The two sets of neighbours live in adjacent multi-million-pound properties in the affluent village of Sissinghurst, near Tunbridge Wells, in Kent.

The Morgans, who are directors of numerous businesses, own Sissinghurst Court, a 17th-century timber-framed house.

Barrister Daniel Petrides told the judge that the genesis of the long-running dispute was the Morgans deciding to erect a new fence between their garden and Mrs Egan’s land to the east.

‘In September 2015, without prior consultation with or warning to Mrs Egan, they cut through the existing wooden fence along the boundary and erected a series of posts on Mrs Egan’s land,’ he said.

‘Mrs Egan’s then solicitors sent a number of letters to the Morgans in October 2015 stating that they had trespassed on Mrs Egan’s land, and asking them to remove the posts. At some point in late October/early November 2015, Mr and Mrs Morgan re-entered Mrs Egan’s land, removed the posts, bulldozed the existing fence and erected another fence with wooden posts.’

‘On November 2, 2015, her solicitors sent a further letter stating that ‘once again you have committed a flagrant trespass onto our client’s land’, but allowing the second fence to remain on certain terms, failing which Mrs Egan would remove the trespassory structure.’

After back and forth, Mrs Egan cut down the second fence. The Morgans then told contractors to build a permanent fence with concrete posts – after which litigation began.

Mr and Mrs Morgan sued their neighbour for destroying the second fence, claiming damages for materials and work.

After an almost decade-long legal battle, the Morgans ran up a six-figure legal cost in the dispute, but they had mostly represented themselves without lawyers afterwards.

But Mrs Egan had used lawyers throughout, leaving her with a £1m-plus bill for the row. Last week, her barrister argued that it was wrong to leave her to foot her bill when she had been the real winner in the case, and amid ‘disgraceful conduct’ from next door.

‘Mrs Egan herself – a 95-year-old widow – has been described in correspondence as ‘patronising’, ‘arrogant’, ‘malevolent’ and ‘frankly poisonous’,’ her lawyer said.

‘The only reasonable response to very extreme abuse of the type described was a costs order against the claimants, on the indemnity basis.’

Still, the Morgans said: ‘This wasn’t about money. It never was. We put a fence up where there had always been a fence. We put it up because the old one had fallen down and our dogs and cats were getting out.’

Mr Justice Tappin dismissed Mrs Egan’s appeal against the costs decision.

‘The parties have been in litigation about that strip of land since 2016, and the appellant claims to have spent over £1million in legal costs, while the respondents have spent a six figure sum, even though for much of the litigation they have been representing themselves,’ he said.

The decision means Mrs Egan is liable to pay her own seven-figure costs of the row.

Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@metro.co.uk.

For more stories like this, .

MORE: Oligarch’s ex-wife wants £600m to cover her ‘reasonable needs’ in Britain’s biggest divorce trial

MORE: Teen riding illegal e-bike who killed great-grandmother has sentence increased

MORE: Girl, 11, has hair ‘ripped from the root’ after it gets stuck in Ferris wheel

Original source Widow, 95, hit with £1,000,000 bill after 10-year fence row with millionaire neighbour

Back to home