You Can See Everything review: When Nathan Fielder meets Elizabeth Holmes the unbelievable truth is next level meta

Why would I deceive you? There’s no reason for me to do so.” Elizabeth Holmes blinks her baby blues and stares into the eyes of Nathan Fielder, who seems unnerved and suspicious but also oddly spellbound. “OK. Alright. Good chat,” he says. But she keeps on staring and nodding and staring. “You’re being real right now?” he asks. “Always being real,” she says, still staring deep into his eyes. But is she?
The buzz around this documentary has been growing steadily over recent months, accompanied by a mystery around it too. Spoiler silence, along with strange teasers and trailers, and rapturous word-of-mouth from early screenings, have established a great deal of intrigue. Now we can see what all the fuss is about it, and believe me, it delivers on all this promise and more.
The film is about Holmes, the businesswoman who founded the health tech company Theranos on the back of a device which could test for many different health conditions from one drop of blood. She was on the cover of Forbes as the youngest female self-made billionaire but things quickly unravelled. It turned out her tech didn’t work, and she was eventually convicted of defrauding her investors and sentenced to over 11 years in prison in 2022. But this film is far from the usual docu-drama profile.

Instead, co-directors Fielder and Lance Oppenheim began recording Holmes and her fiancé Billy Evans at their beach house in California, where they were living with their two children in the last few weeks before she was heading off to begin her sentence. This unique access is layered with elements that immediately lend this set-up the atmosphere of a Hitchcock thriller. Firstly, the way the tiny crew have shot it is a miracle of cinematography, all extreme close-ups and gorgeous natural light interiors; truly, make sure you see this on the big screen. Then the revelation that Holmes is still maintaining her innocence, and indeed appears baffled as to what exactly she did wrong. This delusional mindset is compounded by her relationship with Evans, which seems to be loving and supportive but, as things develop, appears controlling and troubling. By inviting a camera crew into their home for “radical transparency”, are they hopelessly naïve or mind-blowingly arrogant (Evans even showers full frontal for the camera), or so brilliantly manipulative that every twist and turn on camera is by design?
This is what Fielder has to unpick, who becomes the third main character, and actually ends up moving into the family home. In case you aren’t familiar with Fielder — and it’s a big question as to whether Holmes and Evans were — he is a cult comedian from Vancouver who has this incredibly deadpan persona which veers into a kind of straight-man surrealism. His HBO show The Rehearsal saw him come on as a contemporary Chris Morris where he did recreations of real-life incidents; in one episode about pilots, he ended up actually piloting a real plane. In a similar way, You Can See Everything becomes wilder as it continues. No spoilers here, but as Fielder becomes more inserted in the events on screen, there are questions concerning his feelings about Holmes and flashpoints with Evans. When his host does go into prison, Fielder recruits Amanda Seyfried — she played Holmes in a Hulu series about her life, and is persuaded to do so again to aid Fielder’s understanding.

This is next level meta film-making, but at the same time, for all its cleverness and subtle savagery, it is also deeply humane. Holmes may well be neurodivergent, a genuine victim of the men around her, and someone who actually needs rescuing. Then again, she may be psychotic. But what could have been a hatchet job, or indeed a fluff piece, is instead something which looks at humans lost in a post-truth world. Where something might be true if you really, really believe it to be so.
Again, go to the cinema to see this three-hour docu-drama masterpiece, and be prepared to chew on it for weeks afterwards. Film of the year, by some distance.
In cinemas November 20
